Reviews for Anthony's Pizzeria in Marshfield, MA
Food is very good. Wait times are nearly double comparable places. Prices are 35% higher than shown on website (outdated), which... they?ve known for months. Read more
I'm done, I will not be back. First, update the prices on the website to match the store. How long is the menu going to be a... work in progress? Twice I have ordered take-out and was told 25-30 minutes. First time got there after 25 minutes and waitedanother 20. Got salads and they were very good. Figured that maybe they were training people and gave them a second try about amonth later. My bad!! Ordered two pizzas and two salads, Was told 30 minutes. Got there 35 minutes after order was taken(checked time on receipt). Waited another 30 minutes after they had to start the order while I was standing there. Salads wereOK, plain pizza was OK. Had ordered a small Hawaiian Deluxe pizza. Got home and it was definitely small. More like micro withabout 6 pieces of dry pineapple and no bacon like a Deluxe is supposed to have. I should have just eaten the $13+ they chargedme for the one tiny pizza. There are too many pizza places around to be continually disappointed. "Biggest Slice in Town" won'tsave them from lousy service. Read more
Loved the special pizza and we had fun talking with owner. Very nice and clean store.
Nice decor. I've been here a few times. Everything is pretty predictable. Get a sub or wrap or appetizers best bet. Pizza... and steak and cheese r very plain. Read more
I wanted to give 5 stars because the food is delicious. I took one star away for the takeout prep. Very tasty Julius Caesar wrap... and the pizza slice is enormous. Good quality thin pizza with a crispy crust. My only complaint is what you see in the picture.The wrap was barely wrapped. It was very loose. Plus the seam was on the bottom so when I picked it up, everything just fell outfrom the bottom. It was like picking up an upside down soft taco. I will definitely go back, but I would request that they makethe wraps tighter...or at least don't loosely wrap it and leave the seam on the bottom. Read more
Sad to give such a low review to what used to be my top choice for pizza and subs but the last 6 times I?ve tried to get a... delivery order I?ve been told they can?t because they don?t have a driver right now. Either I?m the unlikeliest person ever orthey never have drivers. I know it?s tough to hire nowadays but if you can?t get drivers then stop saying you offer delivery. Read more
I ordered from there at 8 PM on a Friday night 5/6, for pickup at 8:45. Ordered 2 large Italian subs, French fries, garlic bread... and 6 piece honey barbecue chicken tender. The subs were horrible, very little meat, no oil and I was hungry so I took half andas I?m eating there was a piece of hair. That was it for that. French fries soggy terrible, chicken tenders were tossed incontainer and looked the least bit appetizing, the only good thing was the garlic bread. Never, never going back Read more
Super friendly staff and the south shore super slice is amazing!!