Reviews for Binnekill Tavern in Margaretville, NY
We sat at a table in the bar area and it was Karaoke night. Had a great time ordered food that was amazing. Our server was... excellent. Can't wait to visit again. Read more
We stopped in for lunch on a busy Labor Dat weekend Saturday. We were seated quickly on the terrace overlooking the water. The... waitress explained that they opened a little earlier than usual and they were understaffed for a short period of time. That wasfine for us as we were not on any hurry and were spending a relaxing day in Margaretville. We ordered the Swiss burger withmushrooms and it was cooked medium rare, as ordered. It came with homemade fries. It was delicious! I was even able to ordermine with a gluten free bun! Yummy! Our waitress was very attentive and friendly. Highly recommend! Read more
What's going on, you guys? We've been coming to the Binnekill since it opened. Last night, though, was one of worst dining... experiences we've had. We waited 20 minutes to get water, over an hour for our food. When it finally came, the pork bellies,which were always one of my faves, were tough and ridiculously salted. Between the appetizers and before the entrees, the checkactually arrived at the table. The server asked, "will there be anything else?" I said, "Yes, our food would be nice." Heseemed confused. When the salmon arrived, it was miniscule, tough, and flavorless, but much better than the "prime rib", whichwas just a giant piece of fat, and inedible. Needless to say, we sent both back. The chef agreed to let us have the salmon atno charge. I gave it to my son, who ordered the aforementioned meat. Our servers, through it all, were apologetic andsweet. We used to love this place. Please do what you can to bring Binnekill back to what it was. Read more
Food was very good, made with fresh products. The staff was very friendly and helpful. The cocktails could have been... better. The restrooms weren't very clean. Read more
I had pork belly and lamb ribs that were very, very good! The tiramasu was good. I've had better, I've had worse. The staff was... friendly. We ate outside on the water. The ducks were so cute! I will definitely go back, I want to try the Schnitzel Read more
My Husband and I went to Binnekill Tavern for the first time Thursday night. The food was absolutely delicious and the service... was great!! We were in the upstate area in September but the nights we were here the restaurant wasn't open. This time weplanned our trip so we could go to Margaretville and try it out. It was truly worth the wait!! Read more
I got to enjoy a wonderful dinner with my partner and our dog! They were very accommodating with making sure we felt welcome... with our pooch. The drinks were great - I got the dirty vodka martini and it was one of the best I ever had. Our food wasdelicious and came out at the appropriate time- the schnitzel was amazing. What really makes this place special are the lovelywait staff. We’ll def be back! Read more
Nicole rocks her daughter is amazing even with a tourn ACL . Fine young ladies. The food is superb. Making my mouth water... thinking about it. So sorry I'm horrible with names but I hope the young lady has a blast in Europe. Loved everything about thisplace. Read more