Reviews for Tony's N.Y. Pizza in Marco Island, FL
This was some of the best pizza I've ever had. Huge Stromboli (was amazing!), delicious garlic knots, delicious pizza,... sleverything was just super great! Tony and Frank were very sweet as well. ???? I highly recommend trying it out! Read more
A friendly local favorite that I was glad to discover when I was visiting. Now I try to visit each time I go to Marco Island.... Fabulous variety of fresh pizza slices and other great meals. The staff here makes me smile. Read more
Started off with the garlic knots which had the perfect texture to them. Then the BBQ & milk wings were some of the best wings I... have ever tried! The pizza tasted so delicious and it wasn't as greasy as most pizza is! Read more
True to their name, it's New York style and very good! Very generous with the toppings especially the cheese. A group of us... sampled a few different pizzas, all were great. The entrees coming out of the kitchen also looked great. Next time I go I'mgoing to try the Stromboli. Read more
GREAT pizza and sandwiches. True to their statement that it?s authentic NY pizza (we moved to Marco from NY/NJ last year). ... Really nice sauce, cheese and crust. Nicely done! Read more
VERY good pizzas and salad. As a neighbor around the corner from Tony's we are very excited to welcome them to the neighborhood.... We all enjoyed the food and anxiously await them getting their beer/wine license from Marco so we can actually stop in forlunch/dinner and not just take out. We got the Bronx pizza, 1/2 cheese 1/2 pepperoni pizza and the Athens salad - all weredelicious! As a former New Englander, REAL Italian NY style pizza has been lacking (although we do enjoy DaVinci, Davide andothers). The dough is light, sauce sweet and tasty and cheese/toppings very fresh........it reminds me of Papa Ginos/PizzeriaRegina from the NE area. Try it, you'll like it!! Read more
From Chicago and this pizza is incredible! 9 cute tables that offer pizza by the slice, but we picked ours up and gave a quick... heat up again at 450 for about 4-5 minutes. By far, the BEST pizza on the island with a crisp and thin crust! It?s a 10+ forsure! Read more
To Start off Moved from South Bronx NY and Came to try this Place. I?m Very Dissatisfied on the Pizza they Call NY Pizza. 1.... Taste Nasty 2. Not Any Close of Taste of NY Pizza 3. Way to Pricey for a Slice of Pie. 4. Don?t Offer any Lunch Specials. TheyCalled them Self Tony NY Pizza. They should call it Marcos Pizza cause Not even Close to NY PIE. Read more