Reviews for IslaMarrota - Home Of Mr. Crab Cake in Marco Island, FL

Excellent seafood wraps, lots of other options too. Reasonable. Highly recommend.

I?ve been here a few times now that it?s the crab cake place, supposedly new restaurant. Wasn?t impressed the first time. Gave... it a second try. Okay. The crab cake Benedict was decent. Tasty sauce. But the English muffin was soggy. Today the crabBenedict was tossed together and barely on the again soggy muffin. Sloppy presentation and over fried with grease. The saucewasn?t holding together either. And the potatoes were dry, tasteless and not cooked. According to the waitress they are frozenpotatoes. You can tell by the taste and texture. Totally terrible. Why not go with the real thing? . Coffee is warm nothot. Don?t think I?ll be back unless they change up things. IslaMarotta should stick with selling the crab cakes and get out ofthe restaurant business they clearly don?t get. Read more

Great menu and seating are. Outside and in. "The Rachel" its my favorite! I'll have that sandwich every day of the week. Owners... are the best have a great understanding of customer service ideal. You can always go to any other place in the island and waitor just simply come by and seat here. Personally I preferred the second option! Read more

Wow food was SO good! Best brisket I ever had, tender and tasty! Ahi tuna also a home run! Great service too!

Wonderful brunch two Sundays in a row! Our table ordered french toast with custard, blackened shrimp salad and eggs benedict... with crab cake. Everything was delicious! Read more

Outstanding lunch! Great staff of girls making delicious sandwiches and salads in a very tidy spot. Chicken salad (2 ways!) and... blackened chicken sandwich were all fantastic. This place is a little off the path but what a hidden gem. Can't wait to try therest of the menu. Read more

Stopped in for a mid week lunch, it?s fairly new so not too busy. Place is bright with natural light and very welcoming with... about 6 tables inside and a few tables outside. You place your order at the counter and have a seat. Very friendly staff butexpect to wait a bit longer than your typical sandwich place. The food makes up for the wait as my potato bacon soup andblackened chicken wrap were excellent. Fresh ingredients and chicken was cooked to perfection and had great flavor. Willdefinitely return. Read more

Clean, neat and the food is healthy, if you want, ans tasty. Very friendly people own and operate The Lakeside Eatery.