Reviews for Butterfly Café in Marathon, FL
I found out about this place from my mother in law who lives down here. She ranted and raved about how good it was and she is... one hundred percent right! The atmosphere is very classy. Sitting outside on the porch you afforded a beautiful view of thegarden. The food was absolutely amazing and the staff were attentive and polite. Highly recommend you check this place out Read more
we ordered the Tuna Napoleon- some pieces of tuna were very fishy. Scallop Risotto: The risotto was very undercooked Panko... crusted Grouper; Fish was frozen and tough. We had a couple of bites and ended up sick the next day. We did eat the scallopswhich tasted great. Not sure if that?s the reason we got sick. Terrible experience. For a $50+ plate this is unacceptable. Thestaff was not accommodating or understanding. Read more
The food was good, the dessert was delicious, the service was great, would not recommend sitting outside, mosquitoes are... terrible. A little pricey, but overall a great birthday dinner. Would go again just for the dessert, the crème brûlée was todie for. Read more
We checked-in and went to the Butterfly Cafe for our first dinner. Randi took awesome care of us and made some great... recommendations. We ordered the butterfly and key lime martinis and a sunrise cocktail. They were all delicious. For dinner, Igot the coconut shrimp and my husband got the yellow tail snapper. We would both order our meals again bc we enjoyed them verymuch. And how could we pass up the frozen key lime pie. It was a great spin with a chocolate crust and frozen mousse on top.Excellent experience, definitely plan on coming back! Read more
We celebrated our honeymoon here. The food was outstanding, dessert was amazing, ambiance was romantic, etc. What more could we... ask? Lacey was the most top notch server I've ever experienced. When you come, ask to sit in her section -- she'll treat youlike you're her only customer Read more
The food was surprisingly amazing - we certainly did not expect this elevated dining experience. The warm goat cheese appetizer... had a complexity of flavors that was brilliant. Filet mignon cooked perfectly. Snapper had a lot of flavor. Risotto wasdelicious. The service was very professional and genuinely warm. Randi was our server and she was outstanding. Thehostess/bartender was very hospitable - super nice. Highly recommend and would go back again when in the area. Read more
The butterfly cafe is a beautiful dinner room. So beautifully decorated and lit. Unfortunately your experience will be somewhat... ruined because of service. The hostess rolled her eyes at us when we asked for a seat change. I came back the next day fordessert, mind you the restaurant was EMPTY. I asked to be seated at a booth instead of table. She sighed and told us "You didthis to me yesterday, next time make a reservation so we know." Know what? I didn't appreciate that commentary at all. Finallysat and had a different waiter, forgot her name, who was so nice. They could do so much with this restaurant, up the ambiance. Iwas so excited to sit there during my stay at Tranquility Bay, but turned off by service. Nonetheless the toffee cake wasDELICIOUS. If your staying at the resort your should give it a try. Read more
Everything from the appetizers to the dessert was amazing. The ?Warm Goat Cheese? will completely astound you and it is... unbelievable how smooth and creamy the cheese tastes. The Amarena Cherries were a surprising and excellent compliment to thedish that go perfectly with the cheese and toast. The Scallop Risotto was cooked perfectly and it was an absolute favorite ofours. They have only the freshest seafood here and this will not disappoint you, order this! For the dessert, we had the ?datecake? (more like a spice cake) made with a house made toffee sauce that was excellent! The service was awesome, thank youMichelle for taking such great care of us! Read more