Reviews for Big Buck's Homemade Ice Cream in Manteo, NC

Great experience. Ethan was so nice and excellent at his job and was hilarious.

Not worth it. My brother got two scoops of bland ice cream for a premium price. I got a milk shake that tasted just milk. Again,... another place here that is run by kids that don?t seem to care about the quality of their work. The boy didn?t even know how tomake a milkshake and needed serious help. I would stay away Read more

While it was refreshing on a hot day, I did not think the milkshake was worth 10.00. I got strawberry and found myself spitting... out large bitter chunks (not seeds) like they just pulled the leaves off the fruit but left the hard stems in the ice cream. Read more

Very good ice cream, didn't really offer topping options to me, and it is very expensive compared to just making some ice cream... at home. But a decent experience if you're in town. Read more

Excellent ice cream. Customer service was good. We ordered 3 scoops in a cup. There were a lot of flavors so plenty to choose... from. Prices are high but everything is increased in this tourist area. Read more

Lots of cool different flavors! I got a two scoop in a cup and chose the banana and the banana peanut butter cup swirl and they... were both amazing. Really cool that they allow mix & matching flavors with multiple scoops. The two guys working behind thecounter were very friendly and very fast! Prices were great also. They also have a large selection of gourmet chocolates. Read more

Not much of an ice cream connoisseur but the other people in my party were and they were all incredibly ecstatic about their... icecream. Also the frozen strawberry lemonade was a huge hit. And quite large too! Read more

We came to this ice cream shop during a not-so-busy time. Tourist season hadn't started, so I can't really comment on how they... operate during busy hours. I didn't really come for the ice cream but I did like all the options they had for your ice cream. Idid opt for the fudge and it was really rich, soft, and delicious just like fudge should be. We were the only customers thereand the girl that was working there at the time was really sweet and patient while we just kind of dilly dallied since we werenot really in a rush to go anywhere. The prices seem pretty average to me and I liked all the decorations and fun stuff they hadaround. If I ever come back this way again, I will definitely stop back in this place. Read more