Reviews for Pennachio's in Manorville, NY
PLEASE accept this as constructive criticism, as I am only hoping it will help you improve. When you first opened, I came in... personally to tell you how yours was the best pizza I had tasted in years! Literally brought tears to my eyes, it was SO good!But as time has gone by, it has slowly evolved into a substandard product. Not enough sauce, not enough cheese, and for Godsakes man, spread the toppings out to the edge of the pie! The last pie I got had at least 3 inches of space from the edge towhere the sauce/ cheese begins. Hoping to bring this to the owner's attention, my hubby stopped in to speak with him, butinstead was met with a condescending counter guy who dismissed his complaint, and responded with a defense of "just how manypizzas we sell", while refusing to get the owner who was "busy". How disappointing. I guess you could say that this review wasthe only choice I had to voice my complaint. I hope this at least reaches the owner, because I would much rather you bring yourpizza back to its former glory, than to see you fail. Here's to hoping wishes actually DO come true... because boy, do I missthat awesome pizza you once had! Read more
Pizza is swag cuz I heat the slices myself B). Amazing chefs for making the pizzas themselves however!
The worst restaurant I ever went to. I ordered a fresh pie when I picked it up it was cold I asked them how come it was cold and... the owner quickly became arrogant and started yelling at me. I know what happened I got a pie that was laying around not a freshpie I ordered I would never set foot in this filthy restaurant again Read more
Good food and their bread is amazing! I didn?t eat pizza but it looked good too. With that said, the menu prices didn?t add up.... If your going to charge more, make sure you cross out the old price and with a pen write the new price. It comes across asdeceiving (ripping me off). Read more
I love pizza and have been to Pennachio's for pizza several times. I ordered a meat lovers pie yesterday. The pie looked decent... although for $30 I would have expected more than just pepperoni and meatball. When I got home and grabbed my first slice, I wasextremely disappointed with the cardboard crust, absolutely the worst crust I've ever had, worse than a frozen pie at thesupermarket. Luckily I have 2 other pizza places within a mile of my house. Read more
Wow, what a great meal. Had eggplant rotini with a salad. Service was great, very fast with no issues with our order. We went... around 7pm and were able to get a seat without having to wait. Would call our meal $$ as we both had appetizers and a meal. Read more
I recently moved to the Manorville area on the Island and came in to check out the pizza situation at Pennachios. Ordered a... buffalo chicken slice and a half sausage, half plain pie to go and soda. The buffalo chicken slice was phenomenal and that is noexaggeration. Thick bits of chicken in a spicy but not too hot sauce and crust that even if you throw away your crust, youd eatit. The pie was amazing! Thank you for being my new pizza spot! See you soon. Read more
So I wanted to find a local nearby restaurant that did some good catering. So I found this place and hoped for the best. We... first tried their pizza which had a slight decent taste. Though the crust was a bit bizarre and the bottom of the pie wasslightly burnt, they did alright. Our catering choices were penne alla vodka and veal Parmesan. Their veal was really good, butthe penne alla vodka was decent. It should?ve been creamier. I?d go to them again for catering. Just not pizza. Read more