Reviews for Manhattan Pizza & Wings in Manhattan, IL

Their garlic bbq boneless wings are delicious and everyone is friendly.

Definitely hit or miss here. I changed my 5 stars to 3 because the last couple times we ordered, it was pretty bad, either way... under cooked or burnt. This time we asked for well done and the pizza wasn't even browned anywhere. We haven't had pizza fromhere in a few months and now I'm not sure when I'll have a taste for this pizza again... Read more

This place is always been hit or miss for me. Sometimes I have a pizza and it's phenomenal. And then there are other times when... it tastes like a completely different Pizza that I've never tried before. I don't know if they change their sauces or thesausage but I've noticed that it is tasted different from one time to another. I do like the chicken wings as well as some oftheir other appetizers. Prices are reasonable for the area. Read more

My husband and I received a menu in our mail about a year ago and saw something about Sicilian Pizzas and never tried that... before so we decided to be "adventurous" and order one. First time we got a half sheet for just the two of us, half pepperoniand half sausage,onions and green olives. There was a LOT leftover so now we just get the 1/4 sheet and still manage to get 3pieces of each side left over for lunch the next day. ???? Needless to say, the Sicilian Pizza was a game changer for us! It'sthick crusted and hot and fresh when it's delivered every time. We usually only have to wait 45 mins for a delivery.(and that'son a Fri-Sat night too!) We live out of town. Also, you can't beat the price! Better than other pizza places around in myopinion. 10/10. (P.S.* ) Don't forget to tip your drivers! They work hard and gas is not cheap!*???? Read more

We always get a large bbq chicken pizza always super good. Always spot on the money when they give time on pick up orders. Don't... have picture of the pizza but one time the dog pulled half a large bbq pizza off our stove attached is his face he loved italso. Read more

We ordered Pizza and 20 piece boneless chicken wings from Manhattan Pizza and Wings and what I received was 5 piece OVERCOOKED... chicken tenders cut up into 20 pieces. A 20 piece wings is $18.99 and 5 piece tenders is $6.99. So you charge $12 to cut up someTenders? ??????????? I called and spoke to Matt who just said "sorry about that but that's how we serve them". For one you servethem overcooked? And for two, How the heck can you call those boneless wings?? You can't. They're tenders. Over charging forwings when they aren't wings is ridiculous!!! First and last time we will order from this company. We will stick to Pizza 4 Uthat has BONELESS CHICKEN CHUNKS that are way better then some over cooked tenders cut up!! So if you plan on ordering bonelesschicken wings from Manhattan Pizza and Wings just order tenders and save yourself $12. Read more

We ordered a large supreme thin crust pizza & a small antipasto salad. Initial opinion...salad was terrific...very flavorful... and filling. The pizza is stone baked which makes its edges very crisp. We loved that but thought the crust in the middle wastoo thin to support all the flavorful toppings. Will definitely order again either with a thicker crust or Sicilian style. Our order was taken by a friendly guy & ready right on time...no service complaints whatsoever! We may just have found our newpizza place! Read more

This place is a hidden gem, I'm greeted with a smile every time I visit. Their track record on my end has been error less with... food orders. One of my personal favorites is a spaghetti and meatball calzone, a must try! The building is clean and tidy andthe air in the building like a big Italian dinner is being made. I think they are the best pizza that Manhattan IL has tooffer. Read more