Reviews for Villa Milano in Manhasset, NY
First time here, Everything was wonderful, food very fresh, and perfect portions, bread delicious, not to heavy on garlic... rolls just enough to taste . Very clean . Everyone behind the counter so pleasant and accommodating. Thank you Villa Milano fora great tasting dinner. Read more
Pretty decent neighborhood pizzeria/restaurant. Appetizer and entrees all served fresh and very flavorful. The bread was bland... including the garlic knots with barely any garlic. Front store is your typical pizzeria with pizzeria seating. I tried aregular slice?.let?s just say Dave Portnoy was on point with the score. The staff is friendly, courteous, and attentive. Themenu items all priced lower than I expected. Our meal consisting of two glasses of red, appetizer, two entrées plus tax & tipwas just around $75. Not bad at all. Overall a very pleasant dining experience. Read more
This is my must go to restaurant when ever I am in Long Island. Great food and very friendly service. I wish it was closer to... my home (I live in New Jersey). Read more
It's very good, used to be above and beyond - and I've been all over the WORLD (but not Italy). It just wasn't the same. They... had this cheese, that when melted during cooking would release this oil that melted with the sauce - amazing. I've been gone foryears, and it was only this most recent time, but this last pie, while excellent, didn't reach the Above and Beyond taste of thepast. Maybe Covid and the recession has made getting top notch supplies too expensive. Still, it won't disappoint. Cash only,*ATM on-site. Read more
Villa Milano is an amazing pizzeria / restaurant. Service is impeccable and food is universally excellent. Gunny and his... colleagues are amazing and always so welcoming and kind. A friend manhasset institution. 100 percent recommend. Read more
Omg Smell, Flavor, Presentation and the pride they take In their craft is all authentic! I just found out about this location... and it's immediately become my all time favorite Pizza. We will definitely be coming back for years to come. Read more
I?ve been trying pizzas in nyc for 22yrs and we can talk all day about all the spots (Patsys, John?s, Grimaldis, Psp, Ruby,... etc), but the undisputed no1 is this one: Villa Milano in Manhasset. The dough is the perfect consistency and flavor, thebalance of sauce ans cheese, the pepperonis?you just can?t leave a single piece of a slice on the plate. And to top it off, theyare the nicest people you can think of. Hadn?t been in 3yrs to nyc because of covid and expectations about this place just keptgrowing. Once again, surpassed! Thank you and see you soon hopefully! Ps: I took a couple of slice for the plane ride back andthey were still delicious?got some serious jealous stares???? Read more
New to the area and visited villa Milano for the first time a couple weeks ago. My boyfriend and I ordered pasta dishes and... slices of pizza to go. While we waited, the gentleman behind the counter generously gave us a Sicilian slice while we waited and2 drinks. Needless to say, the food was AMAZING! We came back again today for more pasta and once again, (this time anothergentleman) gave us a slice on the house while waiting. I can?t believe how delicious the food is but even more, theirgenerosity! Highly recommended! Read more