Reviews for Reginelli's Pizzeria in Mandeville, LA

Restaurant was clean and staff was very friendly. The kids especially loved making their own pizzas. Will definitely go back!

I have eaten here several times with large groups of family. I really don't think it is anything special. The sauce seems to be... off, and they are over priced. You can literally go anywhere and get a pizza better than here. This place is average at best. Igave them 3 stars instead of lower because they did have good service. Read more

I have never been more embarrassed and frustrated with a restaurant. Let me begin by saying that I have been a supportive... customer of this place since they opened. I ordered a meatball sandwich with extra sauce tonight for carryout. I get there andthe guy tells me he accidentally put no marinara instead of extra marinara. Mistakes happen. I asked them to remake thesandwich-the waiter told this to the cook who wouldn't remake the sandwich. You lost a great customer....will NEVER be acustomer at this place again and will make sure to tell EVERYONE to avoid!! Read more

I?ve recently become obsessed with their Margherita pizza! The burrata cheese on it is amazing and pairs so well with the flavor... of the marinara sauce. Crust is just how I like it too, not too thick, perfect crispiness. Read more

We went there for the 1st time and ordered kids menu for my kid, $7.50 for a CUP of pasta and $3.50 for cut up ONE meat ball!... What a rip off!!!!! Read more

Reginelli's is always good. This was my first time at this location as this is the first location where I now live. The menu has... changed significantly which I suppose happens at restaurants. I can no longer order what I used to and I don't care as much forcurrent menu variety. Still the food was good. Seems like the prices are getting high for a calzone with just a few ingredients.Also seems like my wife's calzone had more outer perimeter crust than I'm used to and less of the good stuff in the middle - seepic. Service and food quality was great. However, I'm considering removing a star but will visit again first. Visited again.This is the Reginelli's that I've always loved. Will be back. Read more

I've gone to the Reginelli's in Harahan for years....many times....twice a week....never had their pizza....but had and enjoyed... their sandwiches the entire time. Went to the Reginelli's in Mandeville last night....and was throughly and completelydisappointed. I've eaten pizza all over the United States....from NYC to LA....and never had pizza this bad....They aredefinitely proud of their pizza dough, as the first pizza had to be sent back, due to lack of anything other than crust.....inan earlier review....I saw mention of top quality ingredents....making the pizza's worth their price. I have no issue spendingmoney on a good product....however....the quality of one's ingredients doesn't matter....if there are such a small amount ofingredients on each pizza. I attached a few photos, to show the lack of toppings on our pizzas....and keep in mind, the FIRSTattempt at the large half Margherita 1/2 Pepperoni, Green Peppers and White Onions was sent back, as it was 3/4, nothing butcrust, including the lack of pizza sauce. The service was fine, had no issue with that. We also ordered a large GumboPizza....could have been a great pizza, however, one shimp and one small piece of andouille per slice, does not make for a goodpizza.....At least from my viewpoint.....especially when I paid $65.16 plus tip....for 2 pizza's, 2 tea's 1 coke and a smallbowl of Naked Hummas....pretty disappointed.... Read more

My husband and I went here for dinner a few days ago. The wait for the food was long but the small pepperoni pizza and the... tortellini pasta we got to share were both very tasty. We ordered the garlic knots appetizer as well, but I could not eat themas they were so extremely garlicky; they made my tongue burn! The restaurant was clean and well lit and, despite it being packedwith people, our server was friendly and patient with us when we needed a minute to decide what to order. Overall it's the bestpizza available in the Covington/Mandeville area that I'm aware of, and I'll certainly keep that in mind the next time I have acraving! Read more