Reviews for Mamaroneck Diner & Pizza Restaurant in Mamaroneck, NY

This us thanksgiving morning 2022. I ordered a toasted bran muffin and coffee. The muffin in 1 minute was cold, had no flavor... and was hard. They never asked me if I wanted a refill for my coffee so I had to ask. Terrible customer service.Don"t waste yourhard earned money ti come here. I sure wont. Read more

Great spot for coffee and carrot cake. Friendly service

I don?t what happen but the diner has seriously went down hill. I?ve ordered multiple times this year and every time there has... been something wrong with the food. Most recently, I got eggs Benedict, the English muffin was burnt black and instead ofredoing it they drenched it in sauce to cover up but the Canadian beacon wasn?t completely cooked ????. They sprinkled burntvegetables and onions over the hash brown. Again, burnt as in black and shouldn?t be served. So yea, I can no longer recommendit. Read more

We've eaten here a few times and have never been disappointed.. The food is better than regular diner food..the service is Quick... .. Location is Great bc of the marina in the back .. And yesterday was a beautiful day to ride around and drop in here for abite to eat Read more

Ordered takeout with some friends. I ordered a burger cooked medium and asked for sweet potato fries. My burger could not have... been more well done, and instead of sweet potato fries, I got a whole sweet potato. Checked the receipt and it even said to cookit medium. Disappointed. Read more

Mamaroneck Diner is a great place to find a quick bite to eat on the go. They even do phone orders. No longer 24 hours sadly but... they are consistent and sometimes have a wait. I?d avoid on Sunday morning unless you have 20-30 minutes to wait. It getspacked! Read more

The Mamaroneck Diner is my favorite diner in all of the Westchester. They just never miss with their quality, and they offer... such large portions for their price point. The staff are incredibly friendly and attentive. Read more

One of the best diners around. Quick service and great food. California omelette and Belgian waffle are my go-to. Their pizza... and toast (yes toast) are also very good. Can't go wrong with any selection. Usually busy and a little wait on weekends. I havebeen coming for years and will continue to. Read more