Reviews for Holy Smoke in Mahopac, NY
I've been to Holy Smokes before but it used to be at the Albany Post Road location. Now they just have this location and the... food was pretty sub-par which is sad because they had great barbecue. We ordered the Philly cheese steak special, full rack ofbaby back ribs, and fried pickles. The fried pickles were pretty good. Philly cheese steak was not good at all. Ribs were fine. Read more
Ordered the ?pig nic? dinner for two for and it was a bit disappointing. We ordered for pick up and the service was great, just... wished the food matched. - ribs were burnt and dry - brisket was dry - chorizos were delicious but dry - bbq chicken was bland,burnt, and dry - mac and cheese was hard, cheese curdled and separated. - creamed spinach was tart (!) - smashed potatoes weregreat - corn bread was hard and dry - bbq sauce is more like syrup than sauce. Maybe everything was made earlier and just kepton heat which dried it all out. Probably won?t give them another try. Read more
Great wings and ribs. Not disappointed ,worth a trip. The beans with the ribs are delish, cornbread is soft and full of flavor.... Wish2 came in the order. Mac n' cheese can do better but edible . The wind came with ranch sauce, not my choice would've ratherhave blue cheese instead. Read more
Amazingly good food! If you are looking for a smoked/ BBQ place, THIS IS IT. The staff is super friendly and it has a cozy feel.... We got the combo platter (PIG NIC) for 2 and it was delicious! Will absolutely return! Read more
My first time here today for lunch was pleasantly surprising. I ordered the combo, which come with 2 meat choices. I chose St... Louis, dry rub, and Texas brisket with garlic mashed potatoes and creamed spinach. The portions were large and delicious. I dolike when a restaurant pours your martini at the table and leave the shaker ???? There was plenty to bring home to share. Read more
Delicious BBQ. The pastrami was the star of the show for me. The extremely warm and friendly staff makes it impossible not to... come back! Read more
The indoor portion of the restaurant is dark and not very nice. The outdoor portion is amazing. Nice tables and fire pit... section. Ample parking. Only 1 bathroom, not very clean. Food: The ribs were amazing. That is the only reason they get 4 stars.Well seasoned, falling off the bone, amazing flavor. Sides were ok. Drink options were ok. A little disappointed on the NY microbreweries options. Service was satisfactory. All in all, I would go back for those ribs. Read more
The baby back ribs were phenomenal, creamed spinach as well, the mac and cheese was lacking cheese and flavor and was served... cold. The chicken wings had an overly smokey taste to it, (possibly artificial) fried ice cream was like a brick. Staff wasfriendly and plenty of beers to try, food could be a lot better Read more