Reviews for Eduardo's Trattoria in Mahopac, NY
Me and my husband just moved to the area this past January, we both pass by this place everyday but read the reviews & was... alittle turned off by it. We decided to come in and give them a shot with my mother & father in law & we all really enjoyed thefood a lot. Everything was tasty & fresh. The chicken was cooked perfectly. Our one and only complaint was yes our server wasvery nice & all but we were there for just about 2 hours, give when we got there, there was only 2 other tables there but therewas 2 servers, the food took very long to come out, which it could?ve been from the lobster. I?m in the food service industrymyself so I get it but it we were there for awhile. But Definitely coming back to try the pizza & more dishes on the menu !Don?t always go based off of bad reviews. Read more
Food & Management is always on point. I have been dining in here as well as ordering out for years. Its a great place to stop in... and get a drink & out of all the pizzerias in Mahopac, Eduardos food is authentic and never disappoints! Read more
I tried this place for the first time after living nearby for many years. We ordered a chicken parm entree as well as the... eggplant caprese panini. Chicken parm was good. The eggplant panini, on the other hand, was missing the pesto, which was a bigdisappointment because it lacked flavor. Also a problem was the burnt bread and the wrong dressing for the salad. It wasexpensive, but my disappointment lies in the lack of attention to the small details that can make or break a meal. Read more
New owner and this place went down. New owner/manager is a total arrogant @hole. I came for a quick bite with my mother and... small child. Never offered to help us with the high chair, pizza was cold, and went inside to chit-chat with the other workers.I asked him for utensils, gave me one set when we were two people eating. I kept calling him and ultimately he called me a liarbecause I told him I had requested two set of utensils. We paid but will never again order from this place. Food was cold,greasy, and pizzas looked like it had been seating there for hours. Read more
Posted a positive review from this place a couple weeks ago because food was good. Now I have to retract it. Recent order was... off, chicken undercooked and menu was misleading. Simply asked for them to honor the menu description and give a credit for thedish that was not properly prepared. Manager was an arrogant assh@le, claimed I was wrong, and made all kinds of lame excuses. I suppose he's never heard of salmonella before. A real shame. All he had to do was address our concerns and he would have hadan ongoing loyal customer. Will never order from this place again. Read more
Fantastic restaurant! Bread is delicious, perfectly prepared with olive oil and spices. Dinners are cooked to perfection.... Portion sizes are great, very good value. Will definitely be back! Read more
We loved the pizza! Portions are big, and the staff super friendly and helpful. They have high chairs for children and they were... super kind to give us a bunch of table cloths to use as back support for our daughter. Thank you!! Read more
Very good food! Nice restaurant atmosphere. Outstanding garlic bread! Highly recommended!