Reviews for Salvatore's Tomato Pies in Madison, WI
Had a pleasant first experience at the Livingston location. Friendly and fast service. We made a reservation ahead of time for... a Friday night. The dinning was pretty full when we arrived. A reservation was the right call for us. Great pizza! We orderedmultiple specialty pizza's. They all looked so good that it was hard to decide. Luckily, our server was equipped withknowledgeable recommendations. The toppings are unique and the crust is perfect. The atmosphere is casual and fun. Hosted afriend from out of state for dinner. Sal's impressed us all. Keep it up! Read more
Great food! Uneven erratic service(which is not uncommon in this time we are in) Food was quality and well prepared. Great chewy... pizza crust. Delicious appetizers were fairly late in arriving. Not overly crowded. The area of booths against the windows are atight space - crowded and small booths. Outside dining great. Read more
Exquisite craft pizza! Crust was light, luscious, and bronzed/browned to a perfect crisp. Generous toppings took it home. Not... Brooklyn, not Chicago or Detroit…not sure if it fits a “standard” category. It cured my pizza fix for a couple days! Good selection of brews. Service was pleasant as well. Read more
Food was great, but most of the food option from the vegetarian we wanted to order were out probably because we were 1.5 hours... before the closing time ? ??????????? Read more
We went there to celebrate my daughter’s college graduation. The service was mediocre at best. Our server was nice, just not... attentive at all. Never refilled drinks and one of the pizzas didn’t come out until the rest of us had FINISHED about meals.The food was excellent which is why I gave them 3 stars. However we ate outside and there was a homeless person perched about 10feet from our table smoking cigarettes for our entire meal. Make sure you don’t choose the front corner table outside if youdo choose to eat there. Very unpleasant. Read more
We had dinner here on a Saturday Night. Service was good. However, we just ordered sodas and there was a delay because the... bartender was backed up…I don’t begrudge them that, it was a little busy…but why are sodas being run through the bar?Maybe they don’t do enough sodas to warrant a separate station. Also, for what it’s worth they have the smallest waterglasses…I think 4 ounces. They give you a carafe so you can refill your own waters a dozen times. The wings with Korean BBQwere amazing. Honestly they were some of the best wings I’ve had. They were perfectly cooked with a little crisp on theoutside without being dried out. They were easy to eat without falling off the bone. The pizza is a hand tossed style. Theingredient combinations on their specialty pizzas were unique and seemed to be above average quality. The large pizzas aregood-sized. They’re priced at $25 for a large. One of our pizzas had fresh tomatoes that kind of bled through and made some ofthe crust soggy. A few pieces of the crust were also overdone…just a hair past the god kind of char on a pizza. Our friendsreally love this place and we can see why. I think we caught them with a couple of off moments on the pizza and we would give itanother try. Read more
The food here is just stupid good! The specialty pizzas are great, but the build-your-own is fun too. We loved getting the... personal size so we could each do our own thing. The sleeper on the menu is their fries... how the heck did this pizza placebecome the one to perfect the french fry?! I thought my dinner date was crazy for ordering fries at a pizza place. Perfectlycrunchy and served piping hot, with a seasoned dipping sauce that we didn't think we liked at first but we both found ourselvesgoing in for more. I wish I could remember the name of our server, because she was amazing. My date got BBQ sauce on his pizza,and she proactively brought out a sample for him to be sure it "was in line with his vision" - who gives that kind of servicethese days?! Drinks were really good too. Vibes are great. Highly recommend! Read more
Plenty of delicious in these 10 inch Pizzas. The wings were absolutely delicious and the overall experience was quite pleasant.... Servers seemed to swap mid service and my first wine selection wasn't available but those are minor issues. The star was thefood as it should be and the Johhny Slices were my favorite. Good crisp and kick on the wings and the pickled homemade greenswere delicious. Good cozy environment to eat. Will come back. Read more