Reviews for Johnny Delmonico's Steakhouse in Madison, WI
While our server was lovely, I did not think my meal was worth the hefty price. The ribeye was small and nothing special flavor... wise and the hash browns just okay. I was pleased at the chocolate torte that was included with my meal for it being mybirthday. High class ambiance, friendly staff, but food not worth the price. Read more
Our dishes were cooked to perfection. Presentation was elegant. Our waiter was on point. I would definitely feel good about... going back. Read more
Delicious steak, friendly and attentive service, high end cocktails - all for a high price that you'd expect from a luxury... steakhouse. Listen to basically all of the reviews and get the hash browns! Subtracted one star because at basically $50+ for asteak, it wasn't absolutely melt in your mouth that I've had before (or made myself). Read more
Food and service were good. Flirting with the bartender was fun. A bit pricey but your paying for the service and atmosphere.
We made reservations on Tuesday night for our 8 years wedding anniversary. It was very busy night so we were glad to have a... reservation. Took long for the food but worth the wait! Professional wait staff, elegant decor (white line tables, high-backtufted booths, nice ambiance etc.) We had yummy Ahi Tuna and oysters for the appetizer, Oysters was very small but they weresaving in huge platter lol ???? Also the lobster bisque which were good too. Of course, the star of the meal, were thesteaks. My husband had a rare dry aged New York strip that was Cooked a perfect medium rare and the texture was great. I hadSeared scallops for dinner which was incredibly tender with a great sear My lovely Daughter’s had deliciously Wisconsin Mac &cheese ???? Oh my goodness! We also got dessert Cheesecake with cherries on top, chocolate bomb with vanilla ice cream whichwas fantastic! I have been here at Johnny Delmonico's Steakhouse before maybe about 7 years ago?.. back then the food was okthe services was fine but Now! I’m so impressed with the food ,they’ve been a lot of positive improvement ???? I’m sure,we will come back again. Read more
Amazing evening had by all, totally fell in love with this place! Amazing staff and Chef's ?? So blessed to be able to... personally thank the entire kitchen staff, wow. Than you Jonathan for making that happen, so honored...truly!!! Read more
Johnny's was our first stop before a show at the Overture Center. Our server was very personable and we chatted about visiting... Johnny's about 20 years ago for the first time. We started with the blue crab salad and French onion soup, which were wonderful.They made the effort to split these for us. I got the ribeye steak, which was prepared just right. The cheesy, shredded Brusselsprouts are an adventure in indulgence! Just a couple of drawbacks: my hashbrowns were a bit overdone and we never got bread atall. I hope to be able to give 5 stars next time! Read more
I took my college son there and we had an awesome meal. Had the mountain of calamari as an appetizer followed by a couple... steaks. I had the aged bone in rib-eye. At home I have a pellet smoker and I hardly ever find a restaurant steak that cancompete with what comes out of my smoker. But this steak blew it away. Honestly one of the best steaks I’ve ever had. Servicewas excellent too. Would definitely recommend. Read more