Reviews for Gotham Bagels in Madison, WI
Bagels are chewy and delicious. Cream cheese flavor selection is full of savory choices. Order ahead with the app to balance... wait time. The banana bread was insanely dry. The portion was huge but it was flavorless, dense, and drrrrry. Stick to thebagels. Read more
I love their Bialys and their bagels. The flavor of the bagels evokes memories of rhe NYC bagels....but he doesn't import the... water. .and I LOVE that they deliver. They are my go to for family gatherings, and especially the Sunday Brunch. Whitefishsalad, lox, Black and White Cookies...and even Dr. Brown sodas. Makes an East Coaster, transplanted to Wisconsin, a littleless homesick Read more
The bagels themselves are still good enough for the midwest, but the owner's New York service schtick runs thin when your food... isn't available until an hour after it was promised Read more
Sandwiches are always great but since the pandemic and closing of the main dining room, other service has suffered. I've always... loved their Cream of Wild Mushroom soup and occasionally the Chicken Tortilla (warning spicy and it builds). With the currentonline ordering...soup is all you get. Pre-pandemic you'd get a nice handful of bagel chips but since the pandemic, nothing. No crackers, no bagel chips, just soup for $6/bowl. Do the left over bagel chips really cost that much extra that they have tobe ordered ala carte? Today I added the black and white cookie and am very disappointed. It's the size and quality I'd expectto get on an airline. That's a normal soup spoon and normal sized hand in the photo. Each cookie is $1. Read more
GOTHAM BAGELS #1 Flat out, this is the best place to buy a bagel in South Central Wisconsin...maybe the best in the state! ... Better yet, it's not just the bagel that's fantastic, the bagel sandwiches, chips, soup, etc, are ALL great! The people that ownand work at Gotham are amazing, too. Overall, incredible value! If you're looking for the best of the best, place an order withGotham. You'll be happy you did. Read more
I?ve never seen such a wide range of bagel sandwich options. I ordered the Brighton Beach, and it was absolutely marvelous! I... mean, those layers are just beautiful. Read more
LOVE Gotham Bagels! Currently dining inside is not available, but you can order online for window pickup. Loads of awesome... bagels and bagel sandwich options. I highly recommend the OMFG one, there's a bit of spice, but it has fried chicken, bacon,overeasy fried egg, cheese, and a pepper aioli. I really like mine on the everything bagel. Read more
I walked up to buy bagels today not realizing they had an online ordering system only. Placed my order quickly in about 2... minutes. Less than 2 minutes later I got a text saying order was ready. Bagels and cream cheese are definitely amazing. Read more