Reviews for Glass Nickel Pizza Co. - Madison East in Madison, WI
We officially LOVE this place. This was our first visit but most definitely will not be the last. The pizza was amazing and the... service was even better. Our only complaint is that it?s so far from home. Read more
Thick greasy delicious pizza with fast delivery, a good bar if you choose to eat in, and solid selection of alternative options... if you're not in a pizza mood. Yeah I have friends who aren't the biggest fans but they've been consistently the most reliablepizza I've had since moving back to Madison several years ago. Could I get more impressive pizza somewhere else? Sure but thisisn't fancy it's comfort and that is why we go back. Read more
Pizza was fine, not the best. I got two veggie pizzas and both weren't very saucy (unless that's how they're supposed to be).... The flavors were average. It didn't have much flavor but there was some. Definitely wasn't worth the price. Ale Haus frozenpizzas are way better. Read more
Our first time dining with Glass Nickel and now we wish we lived closer so we could make it a regular stop. We ordered the... deluxe along with the fried mac-n-cheese bites and it was all delicious. The Founders beer and on-tap root beer were great too.Our server, Angie, was very friendly, helpful and seemed to really enjoy her job. We?ll be back again! Read more
This is one of the best places to get pizza in Madison! It's one of the things I miss the most about living here.
My sister ordered pizza for a family reunion. This place used to be good but lately the quality of the pizzas its going... downhill. As you can see in the pizzas their quality is bad since the pizzas arrived soak in grease. You can see how the box isfull of grease turning the pizza in a soggy/ washy mess and unpleasant to eat. Dinner was absolutely disgusting. Stay away fromthis place. Read more
Easy ordering online and pretty fast delivery; everything was hot and fresh too. Lots of different and interesting specialty... pizzas. I like that you can do 1/2 and 1/2 choices and also choose different crusts like regular, thin, cracker and even glutenfree. They have vegan options too. Then peanut wings were flavorful but teeney-tiny. It was nice that they put the wing sauce onthe side so they didn't get too soggy. Pizza was really good, pitmaster, Boris Karloff, and Mac daddy is what we had. Woulddefinitely order again. Read more
Food at Glass Nickel is always great. Lovely choices of appetizers, salads, subs, pastas, and of course their legendary pizzas.... 10/10 for these things, best pizza in Madison for sure. We order delivery regularly, and dining in is still as convenient ???? Read more