Reviews for Fatty's Pizza (Downtown) in Macon, GA
Of course the pizza is delicious, the cheesy bread is awesome, but I cannot say enough about the people!! I have ordered twice... from here. Two big orders to be delivered to Atrium Hospital. Both times they have been OVER THE TOP ACCOMMODATING!!! Mostrecently I dealt with Ryle (I?m not sure if I?m spelling his name right), he was SOOOOOO hospitable!!! Thinking of every detailI would need to host a Lunch & Learn for one of the departments. He went out of his way to make sure we were taken care of!!Again, the pizza is fantastic, you won?t be disappointed!! I highly recommend Fatty?s!!!! Read more
Pizza was good, wings were okay I thought the sauce would be hotter. But overall cool little spot.
This was my first visit and hadn't done much research into their style. Fattys is about 30 mins from my house so generally out... the way but i was in the area, so wanted to check this one off my list (moving to my must go back list). Walked in and orderedat the register and walked out in 12 mins. Ordered their default 16" Supreme which had the standard sausage, pepperoni, greenpepper, mushrooms and onion for $16. The pizza is akin to Brooklyn style with a super thin base but has that delicious chew(guess thats why it was so fast). The crust had been hit with a little garlic and salt....real subtle but there....great touch. The toppings seemed fresh cut and good proportion to melt right into the cheese. Sauce was just the right amount but deliciouson its own... would love some meatballs and sauce from here. If you're from this area you know IVP if you like pizza. Id putFattys up against them....definitely on that same level.... The only thing I wish was that they were cooking in a wood/coalfired oven. If that was the case, this would be the #1 pizza 40 miles in any direction. I took mine to go. Cashier was superfriendly and sweet and writes notes and dad jokes on the inside of the lids. Building construction in the area limitedparking....probably worse during the week. The inside was a bit dated but clean... just a corner joint serving stellar pizza! Id say this is a tie for the best pizza in macon (but im partial to NY style). Read more
Great place for good pizza in downtown! Parking can be a bit annoying though.
Just got a delivery from this restaurant. Food taste?s pretty good But i was a little disappointed in size/quantity... of Pizza. I got the 16 inch pie but when I opened box I saw more of the box then pizza. With it being so pricey i kindaexpected more. Read more
I ordered a large supreme pizza today and CHEESE sticks !! I got the FIRST PICTURE AND THE LAST PICTURE!! I called after I got... home and talked to SARAH the manager she said she made the cheese sticks that LOOK NOTHING LIKE THE SECOND PICTURE THAT I GOTOFF THEIR WEBSITE!!!! And, I had a pepperoni Pizza instead of what I ordered ! The food was terrible and the service !!!! IHIGHLY RECOMMEND NOT ORDERING FROM FATTY?S PIZZA ON SECOND STREET !!!! Read more
Very friendly environment especially employees. I highly recommend for friends and family. Seating booths were limited however... they were separated safely. There is a long bench for waiting to place your order. Pricing is very reasonable and the pizza isvery fresh. They accommodate substitutions as well. Read more
Our pizza was particularly reheated with vegetables placed on an already done cheese pizza? the cook said the cheese pizza was... just cooked but it definitely wasn?t. The wings are baked and undercooked, the cook was so rude to the other staff! Terribleexperience!! Avoid this place! Read more