Reviews for Trattoria Il Cafone in Lyndhurst, NJ

We stopped here for a quick dinner on a Thursday night. There is parking in the back but also street parking in front of the... restaurant. That was my worry coming here but it worked out great. The place is quiet and intimate, great for a date night. Iordered the Pappardelle Al Telefono and it was yummy! Read more

It was really nice, unexpectedly so. Food is very good. Not crowded. Good service. Nice atmosphere, easy to talk (music truly... on a background) . Very nice local Italian restaurant. Read more

Terrible food.My seafood tasted old, everyone complained about there dish. Even the bread was stale. They need to close.

The quality of the food here is incredible. I would highly recommend it.

I have been all over the world and the food here is by far the best authentic Italian food I have ever experienced. Also the... staff was beyond welcoming and professional. I strongly recommend this amazing Italian restaurant to anyone in the area. Read more

The food was not Italian. It was really awful. We had clams oregenate- tasteless and my past sauce was just awful. It tasted... like paste. I would never come back. Should have gone to Nutley! Read more

Love the food and service, visiting there for many years. Great job the Il Cafone team!

Excellent food and service also I enjoyed the relaxing ambiance.