Reviews for Selena's at Willow Lake Tavern in Louisville, KY

ordered a carry out order and they messed up my order terribly. i paid for chicken and waffles and only got a waffle no chicken.... $18 for one waffle? and then ordered a biscuit and gravy meal and got two biscuits. no gravy. staff was nice, but how do youmess up on one order that bad. receipt even says the correct items ordered. Read more

Found this place years ago on a work trip. It's delicious. Today was no exception. Thought I ordered blackened chicken Alfredo.... Turned out it was blackened shrimp. It was great! Cozy environment like eating on your patio at home. Nice fish pond. Recommend! Read more

Finally tried Selena's for my wife's birthday and glad we did! A wonderful little place. We had reservations, we're greeted by a... very friendly hostess and promptly seated. It's a very cozy atmosphere and a place where you can dress up, or be casual. A niceselection of tasty sounding items on the menu, so deciding was a challenge. We had the calamari for an appetizer. Very nice. Mywife chose the corn flake encrusted house made fish sticks, I chose one of the daily specials which was a blackened redfish withgrilled asparagus and red beans and rice. Very nice portions, absolutely delicious! We are already planning our next visit tointroduce my in-laws coming in from Illinois. Our waitress was on point. Very attentive, friendly and knowledgeable answeringall the questions we threw at her. Thanks for a lovely evening. Oh yeah, they also treated us to a complimentary desert for mywife's birthday. We chose the banana foster. I'm still drooling it was so good. Give it a try. I think you will be glad you did! Read more

Off the beaten path, cute, little restaurant, beautiful patio setting with a water feature. Great service. Fried green tomatoes... (good-a bit greasy, under seasoned), chicken/sausage gumbo (okay-on the spicy side) & charcuterie plate (nice-warm brie, cheese,salami, fruit, toasted slices of baguette), bourbon cocktail (v/good). Will try again. Read more

Brian was our server. He was excellent! He was friendly and efficient. As always the food was cooked to perfection. This time I... had the blackened salmon special w/dirty rice and the grilled vegetables were squash, zucchini and carrots. It was a perfectday to sit outside on the patio under the umbrella by the Koi pond! Read more

We Googled and decided to go. The food is creole based and delicious! Another first visit for us. The menu offers good... selections. And I had a perfect Bloody Mary. The GM came out to check on us and the staff is very friendly. Selena’s was agreat find! Read more

Reservations are highly suggested. I didn’t have them but was able to sit in the bar area. It’s crazy busy in there but my... food was delicious and came out super hot. I personally don’t think they are too pricey. We got a lot of food! It’sdefinitely not ihop. Read more

I’m giving this place a 2 ?? Was passing through Kentucky and my mouth was watering for GUMBO… The GUMBO is out of a... Campbell soup can, shrimp so small I needed a Microscope to find any. The roux was awful and had no seasoning and no crab ormussels, who serves GUMBO with no cornbread? My husband got the Chicken Parmesan which was a great big portion but lackedseasoning. The atmosphere was very nice in the restaurant and our waiter was 5?? Read more