Reviews for The Cellar in Long Lake, NY
The dinner entrees were terrific. The bread served while you wait for your main course is wonderful; warm garlic-sesame bread.... They have had to modify their hours of operation presumably due to the labor shortage. The waitress was friendly and efficient,but very hurried. Read more
Nice little restaurant. Went there while vacationing in Long Lake. Waitress was very nice.
I know the coronavirus has made things a little more uncomfortable but the wait staff was rushing around hectic not really... paying attention didn't have time to actually wait on the tables would throw items down and move to the next table without anyresponse from those dining. The food was so so not a great choice for dinner dining. Read more
To go order: Good chicken wings. Enjoyed the half moon (calzone) - although I'm not sure why they served it with cold sauce.... Really good buffalo and Philly Mac and cheese (we ordered both). Only thing that was a disappointment was the pizza. It wasnot cooked enough and lacked flavor. Read more
To the untrained eye it's just an average place to eat, but it's better.. Their pizza was awesome, wings were exceptionally good... with the house buffalo sauce. Wife says margheritas were very good. Read more
MMMHHHHHHHH GARLIC CHEESE BREAD!!!!! OOOOOOOOOHHHHHH Pizza and dare I say BEER lol all the best comfort food if you are... up camping in the area, or if you're a local Read more
This is not someplace I would ever step into from the way it looks on the outside, but the reviews seemed good and we were... hungry, so wife, kids and I gave it a try. Inside, it is nicer than you would expect. Casual, nothing fancy, but neat and clean.Very friendly staff, great service, and food was pretty good. Looks like at night it becomes a bar, with pool table. Will verylikely eat there again next summer when we return to long lake. Glad we gave it a chance. Read more
Very pleasant staff and delicious pizza. One small pizza is plenty for 2 senior citizens. Nice menu choices. Plastic cups... for beer and wine not so great but we are in covid times. Read more