Reviews for Blue Island Oyster Bar & Seafood in Lone Tree, CO

I have my new oyster spot in town. They nailed the vibe 100% open air seating with the patio. Had an outstanding guitar/singer... outside. (I need to get his name) the oyster were top notch and they grilled some on the patio as well. Make sure to start withthe calamari. Our service was excellent as well. Sharon and Oceana truly understand customer service. All around a veryexcellent place for any occasion and I will definitely be back. Read more

Such a fun spot with a relaxing vibe! We went during happy hour after a long work day. Service was great! Our waitress and... trainee were really friendly and fun. We ordered the oysters, Thai calamari, and the togarashi fries. For drinks, we got theold fashioned and the blood orange margarita. Happy hour oysters were delicious, unfortunately, the fries were a miss with ourtable. Beyond that, we would definitely come back again! Read more

Wow this place is expensive!!! I got the Giant shrimp cocktail in honor of national shrimp day and it was $20. Seafood is always... pricey but my goodness. They were jumbo as the description states and had good flavor and texture. Not overcooked. The cocktailsauce tasted like straight up horseradish though, like overkill, clean your sinuses out. I definitely want to try more itemshere but it will have to be over a series of visits as you can rack up a pretty hefty bill quick. Read more

Came here for $1 oysters on Monday. The restaurant is beautiful and has a great atmosphere. The service started a little rough... but got better. The oysters, movie night roll and calamari were fantastic. The only dish we didn’t enjoy was the Tropicalpoké chop chop. The fish was fresh, however there was no flavor and the dish was very bland. Overall a great place for a nicedinner with friends or a date. Read more

wow the wait staff were so accommodating during Thursdays happy hour rush. the food came out fast and perfect. my absolute... favorite was the fresh fish taco. I asked for the gluten free version of the taco platter and only needed a few changes. theyeven notate on their menus each dish that can be made gluten free! that was greatly appreciated. Read more

My husband and I had date night last night and tried this place for the first time. We made a reservation for 7:45 but they were... able to get us in much earlier. They gave us a glass of complimentary champagne while we waited for our table. Our waiter Victorwas amazing!! He gave us recommendations on the oysters and entrees. His recommendations did not disappoint. The Naked Cowboyoysters ???? were our favorite! Food was great and the service was exceptional! We will definitely be coming back. Read more

Had an excellent date with my wife. The drinks were great, the dessert (key lime pie) was very good. The only ding I would say... was the calamari, which had great flavor but was a bit overcooked. Other than that, we look forward to our next date at thisrestaurant. Would recommend. Read more

We had initial been regulars at the Cherry Creek locations, so when the Lone Tree location opened we were more than excited... about it. We gave it a go & had excellent service, excellent food, & excellent recommendations. The only thing that I wouldsay needs improvement which is completely unrelated to the food or service is the lack of blinds & the mismatched flashing paintin the restaurant. Since there are no blinds in the West Side of the building, sitting on that side & having direct sunlight inyour eyes for the entire meal isn't awesome. As for the flashing paint, it's just my OCD from working in the field. Otherwisethis place is awesome! Read more