Reviews for Locust Valley Pizza Cafe in Locust Valley, NY
Got a Sicilian Pie one of the bigger and better Sicilian pies I've had in awhile.
Omg, had eggplant parm dinner from the soup , salad n main dish, everything was delicious!
When evaluating a good slice of pizza, there are so many factors to consider: the thickness of the bread, the cheese to crust... ratio, the texture, etc. While I think Locust Valley Pizza makes some of the best pies in this area, they are frankly on thebread heavy side. This is how a pizza should be. Read more
Very good pizza at a reasonable price. Very clean store with polite and efficient staff.
Delicious pizza and great service! I ordered a grandma pie with extra sauce on a Friday night and it was ready to go within 20... minutes. They have a clean dining room with plenty of room to eat inside and outside. I'm looking forward to trying more thingson their menu in the future! Read more
OK, a nice neighborhood pizza spot... nothing dramatic about the pizza, but it is consistently tasty and nicely textured with a... crisp crust... Sicilian style very reasonable and delicious some of the competition down the road serve sweet sauce, not mychoice mozzarella sticks and chicken wings are fine and a hit with the little ones, pepperoni pinwheels are terrific,especially for the price if fried calamari is your thing, go somewhere else employees are helpful and polite to the point offriendly Read more
First time here, very impressed! Spaghetti bolognese was great, and a large portion, fried zucchini spears were very good, and... meatball side was one of the best I've had! Wings were good too! Read more
Accomodating staff, price is reasonable. It's my first time to order here the pizza I ordered is too salty and and the thin... crust too tough. I'll give it another try next time for another flavor hope it'll will be better. Read more