Reviews for Old City Prime in Lima, OH
It's always one of my favorite places. Went for a work event and was totally impressed again. One young bartender had to go... downstairs to get the beer I wanted. After that, she made sure i had them available all evening. Appetizers were delicious, andthe filet was amazing. I finished with the lava cake and left smiling. Read more
We chose here to celebrate our 22nd anniversary and everything was amazing!! Loved the atmosphere, the host, our server and the... food was delicious. They really made us feel special. We will be back for sure. Read more
This was our first time ever going to the restaurant. We had heard great things about it. Between ordering and being served was... very very long. Once the food arrived it was cooked very well. Just no flavor whatsoever my wife ordered the beef tips andnoodles zero flavor. I ordered a sirloin the flavor was probably barely on the outer crust the inside was very flat and blandordered medium. Long waits in between glass fill ups and seeing our waitress. Waited for our check to cash out for so long weended up having to find somebody to find our waitress. Had very very high expectations. We drove good ways to get there to onlybe greeted by mediocre food flavoring and okay Applebee's style service.???? Read more
Ate here for the first time last week. Everything was top notch! Our server Stephanie did a wonderful job! Her amazing service... really enhanced our experience. I had the wagyu strip steak which was probably the best thing I have ever put in my mouth. It ispricy but it is worth every dollar you will spend. Hopefully we will be able to return soon! Read more
This was our second visit and we were looking forward to a nice evening and a great dinner. We had a reservation and when we... walked in the host lead us to the table right behind the host stand. We asked for a different table and were told larger partieshad reserved all other tables. Needless to say, my husband's chair was bumped numerous times along with his elbow. Our waitresswas wonderful. We did ask her to space our courses, but about 20 minutes passed between our salad and entrées. We ordered anend cut of prime rib and asked if could be medium rare. The server assured us that could be done. The first attempt was morewell done than medium rare. The waitress was apologetic and asked if a center cut would be acceptable so that it could be mediumrare. When the center cut was delivered, it was also over done and very tough. The waitress sent over service managerScott..what a JERK! First he blamed the server for even accepting an order for medium rare, then argued with us about cook andquality of the meat. He never apologized and rushed away from the table as soon as possible. This "manager " was not helpful andvery rude and dismissive! Certainly not what is expected in a quality restaurant. Scott ruined this experience and I doubt wewill return. Read more
Full menu with great offerings, delicious food, fantastic atmosphere and stellar service from Nichole at the bar! She made it a... 5 star experience. Prime rib pin wheels, table side prepared Caesar salad, Shrimp Carbonara and luscious cocktails. Can?t waitto return. Read more
Hands down the best dining experience my husband and I have ever had. Food was top notch, drinks were made so smooth and the... staff was attentive, knowledgeable and kind. We will be back! Read more
This place was amazing. My first time here. I live in Indianapolis. Great fine dining experience. Awesome atmosphere and... excellent food. Sizeable portions. I had the 14 oz Delmonico Ribeye medium rare, shrimp and crab chowder soup. The Cosmopolitandrink was on point. Our server Scott was amazing. He was attentive, friendly, knowledgeable and efficient. I highly recommendthis place and will return next time I come back to Lima. This place rivals big city fine dining restaurants. Kudos to theentire staff. You did a great job on service and creating fond memories. Read more