Reviews for The New Yorker Pizza in Lexington, NC

This place has really started to fall off the radar as of late. now they have delivery cap, impolite people answering the... phone, and they're prices are way too high to put up with the decline in quality. Read more

Put me on hold first thing then came back to say hello before hanging up on me. Total turn off, won't ever be calling them... again. I try to catch a break and this is what I get. Thanx??????????? Read more

Great food. Their stuffed meat lovers pizza, which you can buy by the slice, or a whole pizza, is some of the best pizza I?ve... ever had Read more

This place use to be amazing but here in the last few years the quality of their food has declined drastically, they are way... over priced and can be super rude to their customers. I use to eat here on a regular but after the last few experiences, I donot believe I will be going back ! Read more

My family and l ordered from here about 4 days ago while on vacation. Ill have to say this is prob the very best pizza l have... ever had! The stuffed meat lovers pizza is delicious! Crust was perfectly done and just stuffed full of a delicious assortmentof meats! Makes me want to drive back to Lexington to eat here often! The calzone was equally delicious with a generous amt ofcheese. Wings were a hit also! I wish l could give this more than 5 stars!! HIGHLY recommend eating here! You wont bedisappointed! Read more

It's an actual shame they can't seem to get things right recently, the food they make is actually good if they actually manage... to get the order right. We were regular customers for over 3 years and in the last year the customer service has completelydropped off the face of the earth. 1 out of every 2 or 3 orders was wrong or missing something, calling did basically nothing asthey are more concerned with arguing that they didn't do anything wrong rather than trying to provide the most basic level ofcustomer service, on top of having no issues with calling us and as well as others liars outright. Beyond the orders beingoutright wrong or missing items, recently they can't even seem to deliver an order to the correct house and then want to argueover that too trying to tell us that we had the missing food that had never arrived and we were liars and even went as far asrefusing a refund for an order already paid for by phone that they made the delivery mistake on. This is a place that has nopride in what they do, no shame in how they act, and they will not care about you as a customer. I would love for this place tocome back around but as it is now all I can do is say to think twice before going here unless you want a 50/50 chance of beingripped off or outright disrespected. Read more

I am only giving 2 stars because the food is great, when the order is right. We have ordered from here MANY times but the... management has been going down for a while and the past months it has fallen WAY off. I could make a list of the issues we havehad but instead I will just say you should have a back up plan if this is your dinner plan. ?? Read more

Located inside a nondescript gas station and has little advertisement except for word of mouth. Which is how we came to stop. ... Friendly helpful staff, ingredients looked fresh. Only 15 minutes from order to getting. Piping hot! Delicious Read more