Reviews for Pizzaiola in Leola, PA
We had never ordered from this restaurant before and we won't be doing it ever again. The time estimate was 30 to 45 minutes,... after an hour I called to check. I was told the driver had already left. 30 more minutes later the food finally showed up.Everything is lukewarm at best. The "large" salad Is average size, and the XX Large pizza didn't even fill the pizza box. Iattached pictures of the salad and the grilled chicken hoagie. Apparently placing cheese on the top of a hoagie is what theydid. It wasn't inside, and it was only melted slightly from the warmth of the hoagie. Definitely won't order food from hereagain. Read more
Ordered a Chicken Alfredo and found a piece of metal inside. The wings were dry and the cheese steak stromboli had barely any... meat. Read more
Went in with high hopes because of all the good reviews. Ordered a cheese steak and fries. The cheese steak was more like a... veggie sub with meat topping (and skimpy at that). Fries were good. Not worth $15, though. Read more
I can say this is one of the best pizzas I ever had in my life! From new york city and was in PA on vacation for a week, on the... last 2 days of our vacation we decided to go pick up a pizza for dinner, AND IT WAS SO GOOD! u could taste the difference in thecrust and ingredients compared to city pizza u could tell they took their time and care into making that pie. The man and womenwho I?m guessing are the owners are so kind. They made an exception to us paying with card and ordering the pizza so late thatnight right before they closed. When we went to pick it up there was no attitude (something that probably would have happenedhere in the city by closing hours ????) instead we were greeted with a big smile and kindness. Anyway our experience was so goodthat we ended up returning on our last night to order again this time we ended up getting two pies!!! Read more
not great pizza. Ok pizza at best, but that alone would only warrant two or three stars, the restaurant also lists prices... incorrectly on their website and does not mention the change anywhere when you order. We are not talking about a couple cents,but just about 2 dollars difference in cost on the sicilian pizza with 1 topping. On top of that the just "ok" pizza is coveredin a VERY thin layer of cheese with holes straight to the dough in numerous locations. The sauce is very underwhelming and lacksflavor. Honestly when I bit into my pizza ($19.07) I IMMEDIATELY thought it tasted exactly like a frozen Ellios pizzasquare. With so many other options in Leola I would strongly recommend steering clear and trying somewhere else. Read more
Friendly service, even faster delivery. First time ordering from their shop, I ordered a cheesesteak stromboli with and order of... bacon cheese fries, food was great, tasted great, can't wait to try more stuff of their menu, I would definitely recommendordering from them. Read more
wonderful place and very good food best pizza I have ever had <3
Great pizza. It tastes amazing. I always order from here. I haven't tried anything else here other than pizza. Always fast... delivery and pickups. Read more