Reviews for Oyster Bay Seafood Cafe in Lawrenceville, GA

Great service and location. Really enjoyed the different choices of Georgia beers. I had different appetizers and plates they... were good but nothing that blew me away to go back. Except the Caribbean shrimp, now that packed a punch in every bite. Read more

First and last time ever eating in this establishment. I ordered the Whiskey Cream Shrimp and it was awful. When asked if... everything was good I informed them I didn?t like the food. The Supervisor said they could remake it for me and I said yesplease but with no sauce because I didn?t like it. She gave me an attitude and told me they couldn?t do that and according totheir policy they can?t take it off my ticket. It?s safe to conclude that this place doesn?t care about the experience theirpatron have. I do not recommend this place to anyone. Read more

The food and the service was excellent. From the crab cakes to the Oysters, to the salad and the desert. If it wasn't so far... away from me, they'd have a steady customer. I'm making my way back up there anyway. It's worth it. Read more

Oyster Bay was outstanding! Everything that we had was delicious. The hostesses in the front were a little confused at first,... but the issue was resolved quickly. We will absolutely be back and highly recommend this spot to friends. Read more

The Excellent: the food. It is superlative! Delicious lobster ravioli, scallops, ribs, and baked oysters. Perfectly prepared,... served in very generous portions. We moved to Lawrenceville recently and are thrilled to have found a local, family-runrestaurant with such terrific food. The Good: Outdoor and indoor seating. Nearby street parking. The OK: Some of the Serverswere very friendly & helpful and others were... less so. Of course restaurants are struggling to find enough help and everyonehas a bad day. The Bad: No club soda or cranberry juice available at the bar. Beer, wine, and soda included in the limitedbeverage options. Read more

My wife and I went here last night and waited for 40 minutes, our waiter found it difficult to find his way back to our table we... had to ask another waitress to get him twice, my wife ordered wine ( 9oz) and only got half, we had lobster bisque and seafoodchowder and the water in the ladies room was hotter! But the chowder did taste great along with the oysters however our entreeleft much to be desired I post a picture of my ? seafood platter ? I ate one shrimp and one scallop from this plate it was tobroiled but it was just warm and no seasoning. I payed over $100 for our meal! We will never return. Read more

Amazing fish dip! We waited 45 minutes, but it was completely worth it. The fish Platter was quite good, the calamari is good if... you like red pepper flakes, and the redfish is tasty. The key lime cheesecake is phenomenal. Read more

The Oyster Bay Seafood Cafe is in a lively location with indoor and outdoor seating. Behind the restaurant, you can find paid... parking through a QR code. Customer service is terrific, along with roomy seats. They only serve wine and beer, but the food isdelicious. It is similar to a nice Mississippi restaurant. They know what they are doing in there, and you will be happy whenyou leave. Read more