Reviews for Frosty's Ice Cream in Lancaster, NY
I have to be honest and say the peanut butter custard had no flavor at all when we were there. Really disappointed. Great base... but no PB flavor that I expected. Read more
Very good ice cream nicely served with fresh toppings. A tad on the pricey side but I would definitely recommend Frosty's for a... good Ice Cream experience. Read more
Wow there ice cream is delicious. Very creamy and cools you off. And fast and friendly service too.
Stopped on a warm day.to enjoy some ice cream. They have many flavors both.hard Perry's and custard. Sundaes.are available too!... Outside seating is available. Read more
Frosty?s is delicious! Since I?m vegan, I thank the business for putting such tasty vegan options on the menu.
Great place for ice cream! Dog dishes are available. Always quite busy during the warm months but it?s a tradition to come here... and sit outside enjoying a nice night in the village. It was a cash only business for a long time but not sure about now. Thebuilding itself it a historic converted gas station and very unique. Read more
I haven't been able to eat ice cream in years. I decided to try the Vegan Mint chip dipped in chocolate. Omg I couldn't... believe how awesome it tasted. They have a whole list of Vegan items. Will definitely be back. Read more
You have to get the custard, specialty sundaes or other custard based creations. Do not waste your time with the hard ice cream.... You can buy Perry?s at the store or any place so don?t miss out on what makes Frosty?s a 5 star ice cream place. The custardservings are incredibly generous and delicious, but the real MVP at Frosty?s is the cannoli sundae. Out of this world if you arelooking to really indulge. Read more