Reviews for Number 1 Pizza in Lake George, NY
Super friendly, open later than most places. I got the penne with vodka sauce and it comes with a full bread roll and small... salad. Good deal. Also had a quick beer while waiting for the food to go. Would recommend, authentic friendly Italianrestaurant Read more
A really great Italian family restaurant. Went with a large group and the service was great. Several people got pizza. I had... the special - spinach ravioli. The pasta and filling were very fresh. Such a wonderful flavor! Also got cannolis for dessert! Read more
Moving up to the Lake from downstate, I was afraid I?d be missing my pizza and Italian food. The pizza here is amazing. The... dishes are terrific- the cannoli are honestly, the best I?ve ever had- home made and assembled when you order them. I?ve eatenthere and taken out numerous times and will miss them when they close for the winter. Read more
The food was fine. The service was unfriendly (or perhaps that?s just their typical personality). The cost of the food was... ridiculous for what you get. $16 for ravioli and meatballs. There were FIVE ravioli on my plate. Five. The sauce was good. Mycompanions pizza was good but cost $26 for what they call a large. Price gouging is real in lake George. I?ve eaten in farbetter cities for a lot less. Read more
My wife and I each had one of their specials: the spinach ravioli and the spaghetti bolognese. Both were very good. The sauces... were different, and neither was sweet, a common failing with tomato sauces these days. The garlic toast was also very good -nice herb flavor. I'd have given them a five were it not for our server, who was not friendly and acted as though our presencewas a bit of an imposition. It is NOT our job to try to make friendly conversation and engage the server; that is the server'sjob. She failed. Read more
Great thin pizza, even better garlic knots. Prices are good, very clean inside, nice staff. Will definitely go back there. It?s... worth driving a couple feet up the busy strip and dining indoors. Read more
Very delicious Italian restaurant. You can tell that the chef puts alot of care in his food. When we visited, Lasagna was the... special and it was great. Pizza is always good and the stuffed shells are amazing. The meatballs are so soft and flavorful. Thisplace is a must when we visit NY. Read more
If you're looking for authentic tasting New York style pizza, but you're worried you're too far from the city to get the real... deal, this is the place. As a displaced native New Yorker, I felt right at home at this place. The staff was kind andaccommodating, and it was a laid back atmosphere with awesome pizza. The name makes it sound like a tourist trap, but make nomistake: the pizza here is the real deal. Thin crust, crispy bottom, cheesy with great pepperoni, really great all around. Read more