Reviews for Lake Geneva Pie Co in Lake Geneva, WI
Every year we get out clients/friends pies from here for their Thanksgiving table. They are a big hit as everyone loves them. ... Working with Jennifer and her family on such a big order is super easy. Lake Geneva Pie Company is the best!!! Read more
First of all, I hate cake and eat pie all the time and for every birthday etc. They didn't greet at the door or make eye... contact. They had pies advertised in their fridges to go that they don't make anymore. There's no complete menu either. Thelady did not use gloves to cut or get my piece of pie; nobody was wearing a haircut. And I saw canned pie filling in the back.Needless to say this does not look like it is a homemade facility with some of the pie. I saw that they had French silk, sowhen I went to ask for it they said they don't make it anymore they have chocolate pie.. And I asked if it was pie filling orpudding like filling and she said no. Unfortunately when I went to taste it I realized that the whip cream was it was like aready whipped can of whip cream and extremely oily and melting right away. The chocolate chips tasted fake on top. The pieitself tasted more of a vanilla almost caramel chocolate flavor.. There was no actual chocolate pie flavor of what I'm used towhen I order it at any other place. The pie was not what I thought it would be, and for almost $6 a slice, I'm not Too pleasethat I spent more money than I would getting an entire lunch somewhere. The pie tasted like vanilla pudding that had slightchocolate added in. Even the color was very light brown. The only positive is the service was friendly once at the front of thecounter and it was clean inside. But I won't be back. Read more
First of all, I hate cake and eat pie all the time and for every birthday etc. They didn't greet at the door or make eye... contact. They had pies advertised in their fridges to go that they don't make anymore. There's no complete menu either. Thelady did not use gloves to cut or get my piece of pie; nobody was wearing a haircut. And I saw canned pie filling in the back.Needless to say this does not look like it is a homemade facility with some of the pie. I saw that they had French silk, sowhen I went to ask for it they said they don't make it anymore they have chocolate pie.. And I asked if it was pie filling orpudding like filling and she said no. Unfortunately when I went to taste it I realized that the whip cream was it was like aready whipped can of whip cream and extremely oily and melting right away. The chocolate chips tasted fake on top. The pieitself tasted more of a vanilla almost caramel chocolate flavor.. There was no actual chocolate pie flavor of what I'm used towhen I order it at any other place. The pie was not what I thought it would be, and for almost $6 a slice, I'm not Too pleasethat I spent more money than I would getting an entire lunch somewhere. The pie tasted like vanilla pudding that had slightchocolate added in. Even the color was very light brown. The only positive is the service was friendly once at the front of thecounter and it was clean inside. But I won't be back. Read more
Bulk ordering ?His,? ?Hers,? and ?Our? favorite cookies worked our exactly how we wanted it to. We packaged them up with baggies... from Oriental Trading Company, labels from Amazon, and custom stickers from Etsy. Everyone loved the to-go cookies! Read more
Bulk ordering ?His,? ?Hers,? and ?Our? favorite cookies worked our exactly how we wanted it to. We packaged them up with baggies... from Oriental Trading Company, labels from Amazon, and custom stickers from Etsy. Everyone loved the to-go cookies! Read more
Decide what pie you want and be prepared when you go to get a whole pie. Slice selections are slim, understandable. At the end... of the day I was going to get 2 slices of blueberry....my only option was a whole pie. Regardless me and my son put that wholepie down in 24 hrs and was so happy we got that in lieu of slices....whole pie is a much better value. Read more
Decide what pie you want and be prepared when you go to get a whole pie. Slice selections are slim, understandable. At the end... of the day I was going to get 2 slices of blueberry....my only option was a whole pie. Regardless me and my son put that wholepie down in 24 hrs and was so happy we got that in lieu of slices....whole pie is a much better value. Read more
Delicious. We had raspberry pie, raspberry orange muffin, chipotle cheese quiche and oatmeal cookie. The quiche and baked... items were nice and moist. Read more
Delicious. We had raspberry pie, raspberry orange muffin, chipotle cheese quiche and oatmeal cookie. The quiche and baked... items were nice and moist. Read more
Cute place. Slow service. Great pie! I would have liked to see prices and pies available by the slice on the chalkboard. Only... prices advertised were the beverages and a price on a whole lemon meringue pie. After purchasing 2 slices, I'm guessing it'sabout $5/slice. Read more
Cute place. Slow service. Great pie! I would have liked to see prices and pies available by the slice on the chalkboard. Only... prices advertised were the beverages and a price on a whole lemon meringue pie. After purchasing 2 slices, I'm guessing it'sabout $5/slice. Read more
Wonderful friendly staff, amazing assortment of pies to choose from, soups and quiches also available, delicious as they look!... A must stop if you are in the area! Best chocolate cream pie I ever had! Read more
Wonderful friendly staff, amazing assortment of pies to choose from, soups and quiches also available, delicious as they look!... A must stop if you are in the area! Best chocolate cream pie I ever had! Read more
An amazing hidden jewel in beautiful Lake Geneva. Super friendly, family run, everything made from scratch, and their award... winning pies absolutely live up to the hype. They must make hundreds of pies everyday. The line is usually out the door. So ifyou want to get your favorite pie come early, or order ahead. Read more
An amazing hidden jewel in beautiful Lake Geneva. Super friendly, family run, everything made from scratch, and their award... winning pies absolutely live up to the hype. They must make hundreds of pies everyday. The line is usually out the door. So ifyou want to get your favorite pie come early, or order ahead. Read more
Every year we get out clients/friends pies from here for their Thanksgiving table. They are a big hit as everyone loves them. ... Working with Jennifer and her family on such a big order is super easy. Lake Geneva Pie Company is the best!!! Read more