Reviews for Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop in Knoxville, TN

Since before Thanksgiving of 2022 the Apple Pies 4? & 9? have raw crusts. It?s not that nice hard crispy pie crust that they... used to have. I am not sure who?s baking pies without training or watching the quality of the pies. This needs to be fixed. Read more

Excellent pies, fresh baked, good prices and very friendly and knowledgeable staff

First time ever here to this quaint little pie shop. Not a lot of selection for my taste buds, but I chose the Granny's Apple... which was quite good. Read more

Services was good. I brought 2 pies Pecan pie and the new Caramel pie. I ask if the were made today. She replied yes. Honestly... I would say the Pecan was a couple day old. There was no gooey filing and crust just crumbled apart. I know it?s only $5 butwhen you take them to someone and you drive twenty minutes out your way you want them to be fresh. Just saying if you sellingday old it should be posted. Read more

Fantastic pies! We were visiting from out of town for my birthday and I prefer birthday pie over birthday cake! We got the... large apple and two small pecan and peanut butter. I could eat them all day. Read more

Horribly disappointed. We made the mistake of getting the strawberry pie. Oh my goodness it?s TERRIBLE! You might as well open a... jar of strawberry preserves and pour it into a pie shell. We honestly couldn?t tell the difference between this awful pie andthe strawberry jam we had in the fridge. It was sickening sweet too. ???? And way overpriced! Read more

All their desserts are yummy. And service is great!! Hands down one of the best desserts in town.

My two son's and I was greeted with a warm welcome at the Butter Milk Sky Pie. We order the buttermilk pie and key lime pie the... made from scratch crust. The key lime pie was topped with special lime whipped cream, the best key lime pie this world. Thisholiday season will not be complete without a fresh baked buttermilk sky pie this year. Read more