Reviews for Pepi's Pizza in Kitchener, ON

Worst pizza I've ever had. Crust was burned black and falling off. Crust was also crumbling apart from UNDERNEATH the whole... slice, you couldn't even pick up a lot of the pieces (what the heck?) and didn't taste like regular pizza dough, closer tobiscuit texture. Some pieces were fat, some were slivers or just broke in half from the top. Toppings were just dumped on, WAYtoo much. Pizza was so spicy my 6 year old stopped eating it and I couldn't give it to my 2 year old. At first I thought it wasjust the banana peppers we got on 1 half but it wasn't that kind of spice and it was both sides, like it was in the sauce??Super disappointing for a pizza night we were looking forward to. Just threw it out. Read more

This pizza was terrible. The large pizza looked like it was XXL and thrown together. None of the toppings meld together. The... wings were mushy. I felt like I tasted a meal from a teenager that?s learning how to cook. I?m going to end up throwing awayhalf of the pizza. The other reviewers are crazy or 0 taste in food. Read more

I ordered a lb of wings and lasagna dinner and it was horrible!!!the water street pepi's was the best until new owners,the... marinara is not homemade like it used to be!!!I'll never order from pepi's AGAIN!!!32$$$ FOR DOG FOOD Read more

The Water Street Pepis Pizza has some beautiful old woodwork and stained glass. the washrooms are updated and clean. The staff... are nice, fast, they always wear gloves while handling food and care about your satisfaction with your order. There are sixtables for 4 and two tables for 2 if you are planning to go out for dinner. The big screen t.v over head gives it a sports barfeel. Now the food!! Their Pizza is exceptional of course. They use real ingredients like bacon strips and fresh mushrooms. Theyoffer subs,wings, lasagna and salads including Ceasar's and a few types of pasta salads which are homemade. See photos below. Ihave to mention the Munchies bacon sub. It weighs a couple pounds for anyone with a big appetite or ready for a challenge. Youcan order double meat and really give your belly something to brag about. It's so good toasted with extra chesse. Fordesert; You absolutely must give yourself a treat and try a big slice of home made cheese cake with several kinds available likechocolate and caramel, oreo cream and layered berries. I had raspberry red velvet cheese cake last time and it was amazing. Okaythat's all I can think of but try it yourself. A truly famous icon pizza place only in Kitchener Ontario. HAPPY EATING. P.s. ifdowntown isn't your thing they have one out in the fairview area on old King St. between Kinzie and Fairway Rd. Take out anddelivery only. ???? Read more

I feel bad leaving this three star rating. The pieces always been great food. But I was very surprised that there a great food... has been changed over the years like everything else. One of the greatest things was there potato salad and now they?ve takenout the bacon and it is so salty I can?t even eat it. Very disappointed that they?re changing their ingredients. It happens witheverything out there If it?s a matter of vegetarian then you should have the bacon on the side. People really like to keep thething that they love but when you change it it makes them not want to come back. The only reason I loved this potato salad wasbecause of the bacon and the purple cabbage and the fact that there?s skin on the potatoes. Really really disappointed did nottaste anything like the old recipe. Probably won?t come back. I came from Toronto for the salad. Very disappointed Read more

I don?t remember why I stopped coming here but I?m glad I came back. Their pizza?s taste unique with a sweeter sauce and... crunchier crust than most. Service was great as were some recommendations on dessert (I highly recommend the carrot cakecheesecake!). I ordered through the website and it was super intuitive and quick! Order ahead of time as these aren?t made asquickly (or commercially) as some of the competition that make a pizza in 10 min. Classic pepperoni is always a great place tostart at Pepi?s or mix it up a bit with their wide variety of toppings. Read more

We used to be loyal customers when it was quality! It was the best pizza available anywhere but it's sadly ruined with low... quality toppings! What a disgrace to the quality and value that the original owners produced for they're loyal customers! NB*I'msure you miss our business and the business from other loyal customers! Read more

Best subs anywhere hands down. They come toasted in the oven with a unique sauce that takes these subs to a serious other level.... A must try with extra extra sauce. Read more