Reviews for The New York Pizza Company in Kissimmee, FL
The pizza here is really good. It?s priced right and when I reheat it the next day it tastes even better! I love the mushrooms... they use and they know how to put just the right amount of cheese and sauce. If you like fresh, simple, great tasting pizza?eathere. Don?t let any negative reviews deter you because some people are honestly impossible to please! Read more
This was ok but not the best NY pizza I've had in florida. It wasn't quite done so the crust was way too chewy. The order was... ready upon arrival however, they had forgotten an app, which is not on the menu (and I forget the name of them) so they made upfor the delay by doubling the app order...which was nice of them but they were not good so having 10 of them wasn't good. Theylooked like mottz sticks but were breaded ham. It was mostly breading inside and crust. They were not filled with much ham. Iwould not order them again. Read more
I will never buy a pizza from them! After I ordered a pizza and waited more than 45 min for a doordash order they cancelled my... order and now I have to wait days for that money back! I rodered my pizza at 7:07 pm and they close at 8pm so I don't understandwhy they accepted the order and then after more than 45 min they decide to cancelled my order. I think that isn't fair that'swhy I will never buy again a pizza from you. I prefer other pizza than this company!!! Sometimes they don't give sauce for thewings while you pay for that sauce. You have to be careful of that. They will steal your money too, honestly not lying. Read more
Anyone who thinks this is new York pizza ???? has never been to New York. No sprite or 7 up either. I didn't care for the lemon... loaded ice tea either. Stick with Walmart pizza. Better! Staff was friendly and place is clean. Orange soda is good . Gotta havesomething to settle your stomach after that. Read more
Me and my wife love this place, but today we were disappointed. Not sure if girl taking orders did not know what she was doing,... but ordered 2 slice with drink and 2 beef patties with drink. It took over 30 minutes for 2 patties and pizza not even ready.When I finally got my order both patties and slices were BURNT!!!! I am going to take another chance next time as this is thefirst time this happened to me, but I hope we dont get disappointed again. Please dont let me down. Thanks Read more
The pizza is really good. But one of the employees, a tall young girl was very rude. We have been going there for years and... never had a problem. We ordered online and then we decided to eat in the restaurant, she came on to us very rude telling us wecan't eat inside because the lobby was close at 8pm. We didn't know, there was no sign stating that information. Is a shame,because is a good pizza place, but that kind of employee will draw people away. Read more
Love this place wen they get it right! Gave 3 stars simply because the pizza was undercooked and the baked ziti needed more... salt. The pinwheels needed for the meat to be put inside while u bake it not added on top after also wasn?t cookedthoroughly..garlic knots r on point tho???? Read more
On three separate attempts, I've tried to give this small business, and unfortunately each time either the service or order was... unsatisfactory. First attempt, did not receive full order but was charged. Returned the following day and order was stillunsatisfactory. Second attempt called in the order and was told it would be ready in 20 minutes. Arrived and had to wait anadditional 30 minutes. If I would have know it would take almost an hour. I would have canceled the order on the spot. On thethird attempt and again unsatisfactory customer service. It's just pizza, seriously. To say the least, I can no longer return tothis place of business. Read more