Reviews for Nick's Fishmarket Maui in Kihei, HI
Absolutely loved it. Great food and atmosphere with Excellent service. Favorite dish was the Pan seared Ahi on Rissotto. Tried... Escargot for the first time here and actually loved it. Priced right for a special occasion. Read more
The service and food were Outstanding. Our server Cheston did a great job. The uku piccata fresh local Hawaiian snapper was... delicious along with a filet mignon created a perfect surf and turf.Dessert was flaming strawberries. Check out the art on theplates. A surfer and volcano All this under the beautiful stars. Read more
Excellent food. Friendly, hospitable front of house staff. Ambience very typical of outdoor-style resort restaurant. The only... reason I give it 4 stars instead of 5 is because we ate at Duke's the night before and had a similar, excellent experience butfor almost half the price. Read more
Absolutely wonderful dining experience. Despite 5pm reservation we were not rushed at all. Bill our main waiter was terrific... with great recommendations. We had the Ahi appetizer, followed by beet salad (they split it for us unlike most places when youshare one) followed that with the fish of the day Opaka paka. Chocolate brownie dessert was also delicious. All staff was trulyamazing. Watch out Mama's Fish House, this was a truly amazing meal!!! Read more
Great spot located inside the Fairmont! The atmosphere is excellent with indoor and outdoor seating. Our waiter, Cheston, was... one of a kind. He made great suggestions which all were on point. I had the rack of lamb and it was fire ????. Everything wehad from drinks to dessert was sensational. This is definitely a good spot in Maui. Be prepared to spend some money ???? here! Read more
This place really impressed me. It was one of my top favorite restaurants on the island. The service and food were excellent! I... had the mahi-mahi with capers and rice - highly recommend! The sauces were to die for! I would’ve come here twice in one tripif I had known it was this good (we went in our last day). We will be back! Read more
The food here is so fresh and delicious! My goodness. We had the Mahi Mahi and fresh catch of the day which was Monchong and was... so delicate and decadant in taste, not fishy at all. For appetizers we had escargot and the chef sashimi of the day - yellowfin.Both melted in our mouths. The atmosphere is lovely at the Fairmont, mostly outdoors with beautiful views of the hotel and water Read more
Came here for our 1 year anniversary. Food and service was just awesome. First, compliments to our waiter Bill. He was... thorough when he needed to be and kept space at the right times as well. He was always super helpful. Even caught our foodenvy at times and explained which dish we were eyeing up. Extremely friendly, even when one of his other tables was beingrude. Our meal.. Bill talked me into the Abalone and it couldn't have been better. My wife had the scallops and tortellini,which was equally as impressing. Surprised how great the handmade tortellini was! For dessert we did the strawberries. Comeswith quite a show and presentation that did not disappoint. Would recommend this to anyone! The strawberries were fantasticwith the fixings and the grand Marnier. The meal was expensive (even above what we usually consider expensive), but we knewthat going in. The key is that it was worth every penny. Thanks for the wonderful experience Bill ???? Read more