Reviews for Old Town Tavern & Beer Garden in Key West, FL
Food was good and the half price apps can't be beat. Our server Jason was friendly and attentive. They have two sets of happy... hour times as well. Read more
This place was cool. Seemed more like a locals bar than a tourist location, even though it's on Duval. The people were nice to... talk to (not just the servers and bartenders, but the patrons, too), they had a good selection of beer, the pricing was good,and they have happy hour. Also, try the fried mozzarella, you won't regret it. Read more
Not impressed with this place. When we walked in there was no one to greet us. Finally got ahold of someone who said seat... yourselves. We went to sit on the patio and after being ignored for a very long time, had to go inside to let the waitress knowwe were there. We would have left but it was pouring down rain. Paid extra for bacon in my Bloody Mary, which came out cold outof the fridge, you could see frozen fat on it, it was also soggy. Flat bread appetizer was actually good. But providing howawful the service was, we asked for a check to go eat someplace else. Drinks were expensive. I don't recommend. Read more
Not a bad place. Wouldn't say it necessarily has an Irish pub feel. It has dark wood and the right beers, but other than that... it's a regular bar. That said the service is top notch and the beer is excellent on an island full of IPAs. The food was goodstuff. I had the fish and chips and the wife loved her flat bread pizza. There is an outdoor seating area that gives greatviews of upper Duval. Read more
Great place to eat and the 2x happy hour is amazing. I have never seen that before. You get 50% off flat bread and shareable... items. I think they also do something with alcohol but I don't know what it is. I got the pork belly, the flat bread pig andpickle, and the chicken wings. The pork belly was pretty good and the flat bread pig and pickle was surprisingly amazing! Thewings, jerk, was just okay. My friend got the barbecue chicken flat bread and the tempura asparagus, they were both pretty goodas well. We sat at the bar and Justin was our bartender and he was on it, taking care of everything without having anyone wait.He's definitely the spark plug of the bar. I would give this place a 4.5 but I'll round up. Read more
The key lime colada was amazing! The restaurant is dog friendly. The staff was friendly and there was plenty of seating. The... food was hot and fresh! Definitely recommend. Read more
Gorgeous old bar and a great bartender! Michelle was a blast! She made me a delicious margarita and we had the pork belly app.... They were nice and crispy! I also had a Smithwicks and the taste was spot on, taps were clean! Read more
We were here for the first time and would definitely come back again to eat. Everything was delicious and our server was very... sweet. Great place with indoor and outdoor seating options. Read more