Reviews for Old Town Bakery in Key West, FL
Great service. Any place I visit and I can say that before I even talk food, I know it's going to be good. Got the Italian with... mayo. Very good, but the chocolate croissants...good luck leaving town before you have to go back and have another. Can onlyimagine what the brownie is like, I'll find out. Read more
After a 2 mile bike ride we were so excited to arrive at the quaint little bakery. But what it lacks in front of store size, it... apparently surpasses in baked in love. My goodness, first we couldn't decide what to get between several different craftedcroissants, danishes, muffins, baguettes, breads, and sandwiches so we basically got one of each! Each one just as amazing asthe next. Expect some of the flakiest pastries with incredible fruit slices or jams. The coffee is an added bonus but mind thebike ride as you may lose some! Read more
Was very surprised to find amazing croissants here! I ordered the sticky bun and it was also made with croissant dough and was... super flaky, butter, and the pecan sticky topping was amazing. My partner ordered a breakfast sandwich and it was also reallygood and filling. The key lime pie here is also pretty good. Read more
Ordered a turkey sandwich with pesto on a baguette, with a house brew. Delicious! Edit: We went back the following day, but... right after they opened. Tried the blueberry danish ????, the sticky bun ????, and the almond croissant ????. They are seriouslyamazing. The flakiness of the pastries is perfect. So, so yummy. Will be returning the next time we make the trip to Key West.Good job Old Town Bakery! Read more
Cannot say enough good things about this place!! Peach scone, blueberry cream Danish, bfast sandwich on croissant, key lime pie... - so good!! we came 3x in a 12 day stay up on big pine key. Always quick and friendly service! ???? Read more
The guava cheese pastry, apple cobbler Danish, cappuccino and iced Cafe con Leche were perfect. I also had a roast beef sandwich... on a baguette which tasted phenomenal but the baguette was super hard so it was difficult to eat. Also they just put toothpickthru the sandwich to hold it together and threw it in a paper bag without being wrapped or anything which was odd. I highlyrecommend not getting a sandwich on a baguette and instead get it on regular bread. The service was fine but the cashier wasn'tvery friendly. Also there is no place to sit and eat. Read more
We came here for a slice of key lime pie since I saw it on many lists for places to try key lime pie in Key West. I really... loved the filling. It was perfectly tangy how I think it should. Many of the others we had were not as tangy. The crust, on theother hand, was not good. It was the worst crust of the 5 pies we had. That being said, it's worth having for the filling alone. Read more
I stayed in key west for a week and had breakfast here just about every single day! The café con leche is perfect, all the... baked goods you can tell were just made that morning, absolutely delicious every time!!! Read more