Reviews for Four Marlins Oceanfront Dining in Key West, FL
Well, they earned 2 stars. The rooms themselves were 5 star. Some of the nicest rooms on the island. However, I paid for an... ocean view that cost me $1,500 more for our stay than the kids room. However, all I could see is palm trees outside my room. Thekids room had such a better view and was $1,500 less. Don?t do the upgraded room view. Totally not worth it. The staff seems tomake the difference. The drinks are good as long as the right bartender is making them. The food is good as long as the rightchef is working and the service is good as long as the right server is serving. We have been staying at The Reach and this barand resturant is their in house. It has been inconsistent since we arrived with points where service was bad or great dependingon who is working and the food has been just as inconsistent. The menu is clearly designed by someone who knows food, but theexecution lacks that personal touch from a local place. I still recommend them, but be aware that one day may be different thanthe next. Overall we are disappointed in the stay and don?t plan to come back to The Reach. Read more
Hands down, one of the best dinners my family and I had! The blue crab and conch fritters were the best in Key West, and all our... entrees were stunning and delectable. We tried a lot of different key lime pies while down there, and Four Marlins absolutelyhas the best, no competition. Our server was amazing, and we loved the ocean views on the back patio. Read more
Danny was out waiter he was very observant to the needs of the table while also not being overbearing loved his energy also had... a good atmosphere. The food has great flavor and so was the presentation. Read more
Drinks were really good, although definitely tourist prices. The Smoked Rum Old Fashion is a need to try! The Spicy Pineapple... Margarita was equally great. In the 3 days we spent here, we tried each of the specialty drinks and they were all phenomenal.Tried the appetizers, the wings were fantastic as was the house salad with palm hearts! Read more
Excellent food and friendly staff.... Definitely not your typical hotel restaurant. Breakfast is plentiful and delicious....... Dinner is also great upper scale quality. Typical prices for the key West area... As a diamond member, you get a $15 allotmentper guest ???????? Read more
We are local to Key West, but had our first dining experience at Four Marlins last night - my husband and I celebrated our... anniversary there, which was very special because we were married at the Casa Marina (sister property). The entire experienceand meal was amazing! Our server, Daniel, was very professional, took time to explain the menu and specials and gave greatrecommendations . He also let us take our time, we never get rushed. We will definitely dine here again - it was lovey for aspecial occasion and the ambience was perfect! Read more
Breakfast was great! Nestled inside a hotel, Our server Tim was one the best! This eatery had a small but truly excellent food.... Bloody-Marys and cappuccino martinis were awesome. Read more
Great food, it?s one of the best restaurant in Key West! I don?t get why it?s just at 4.1 rating? It deserves 4.7-4.8 for... sure. Burger for kids are very special, Octopus salad is great! Key Lime Pie is the best in the keys! I tried in many places,but this restaurant makes really the best key lime pie! Read more