Reviews for Eaton Street Seafood Market & Restaurant in Key West, FL

We had lunch here and was pretty decent! Lobster sandwich was decent but little over priced. Tuna sandwich was literally... tasted like the canned but not sure. Shrimp Taco was pretty good ???????? wish there were three instead of two ???? Buildingis cute, neat, and cute restaurant. It has a good atmospheric view and mood???????? Read more

Worth stopping. I drove by the sign outside a few times advertising lobster rolls. Finally having a girlfriend "all-in" to stop... for lunch, we were not disappointed. Take the time and enjoy how delicious their food is! Read more

Great place, stopped for lunch and shared the Lobster Roll and had some visitors join us! We also took some seafood home with... us, very good! Very pricey for the seafood though. Spiny Lobster was outrageous, seriously outrageous. So we took home thesmoked fish dip excellent and Key West Pink Shrimp! Affordable and awesome. You shouldn't charge so much for the Spiny Lobsterespecially when it's Lobster season in the Keys! Read more

looooooooved the seafood here, was amazing and so fresh after a hot day in key west. we got the grouper salad, the salmon salad,... a shrimp basket with fries, and onion rings. the shrimp and onion rings were fried to perfection and deliciously crunchy, andthe grouper and salmon salads were super light and fresh but definitely very filling. the outside seating was really chill too,definitely a cute place, and the customer service was excellent. super recommend ! :) Read more

We enjoyed our time at Eaton street! Both my mom and I had the crab cake sandwich and my dad had the fish sandwich . I asked for... extra sauce on the side to dip my sandwich in and it was delicious! My dad also ordered the conch soup and was disappointedbecause it was basically tomatoes soup with a hint of conch. Keep in mind the photo of the seating area is basically the entirerestaurant except for three bar stools inside where you order so if you are looking for an escape from the heat while you dinethis may not work for you. Read more

Some of the freshest and best seafood, anywhere, served al fresco or to take with you. This is a great place to eat as much or... as little as you want and enjoy every morsel or take it home and cook it yourself. There's no hard liquor but most anythingelse, with a good choice available. Highly recommended! Read more

Super helpful staff. Fun experience ordering fresh and having staff prepare for us. Had excellent fish tacos. Want more fish... ???? ????. They were huge. And still want more. Freshest pink shrimp in town. The delicious peel and eat shrimp and stone crabare reason enough to bring us back. But when we come back we are trying the shrimp salad and the crabcakes. Read more

Great Food!!! My boyfriend and I ordered a 6 inch lobster roll, a 8 inch lobster roll and a bowl of cram chowder soup. They... served fast and with lots of lobster inside rolls!! It was great ???? Soup was not salty and little bit light tasted. I likethat also. Foods are very delicious ???? All staffs were welcoming and friendly. Outside seating areas are clean andspaces. Overall was great experience! I highly recommend this place! Read more