Reviews for Tobys Original Little Italy Pizza in St. Petersburg, FL

The Philly was good. The Stromboli was way too much cheese. I got pepperoni and mushroom Stromboli. Barely any toppings inside. ... Just oozing with cheese. I couldn't finish it. Read more

This is an UNBELIEVABLY amazing hidden gem in a strip mall. Probably the BEST pizza I've ever eaten. Staff were super friendly.... This place was super busy with carryout, they were pumping out pizzas left and right. If in the area this is a MUST!! The"small" is a 16inch pizza for $20...what a freaking deal. We had the white pizza and added ????..yummo!! Read more

It may not look the best but it was tasty and reminded me of my hometown pizza joint in PA. It was cheesey and have enough... toppings for a supreme pizza. The sauce is a sweeter type which goes well with the style of the pizza. Glad I finally got totry this place. Read more

I have to say, this place was booming. Take outs, eat ins, and deliveries. I got there around 730pm and there was standing room... only. I ordered a Stromboli and Garlic knots. My order was made pretty quick, I would say within 20 min. Just listen for yournumber since it gets a bit noisy in there. All of the staff were very friendly and interactive. All the food I ordered wasamazing and filling. From what I saw their pizza are huge. I will definitely make this a stop again when I'm back in town. Read more

Still on my quest visiting pizza joints that serve slices...I used to go here back in the 90's when I lived close by and now I... live close again and in need of slices. As usual I order two slices and a drink, they to have fountain service but this time Ioped for a bottle. It was around one thirty when I arrived and was surprised to see how busy it was. It took the usual fiveminutes to receive my slices after ordering. They could have used another two minutes but good just the same. Being authentic,they do use quality ingredients. The cheese and sauce were great and the crust crispy. If you bring your children, they have agame area in the back with seating. I would recommend this place to anyone who finds them selves in the area needing slices. Iwill have to come back and try the cheese-steak, that will be another quest. Read more

Hold UP. Did we just find the best NY style pizza yet? YES we did. Thin, crispy crust, I wish I could just order crust from... them. The pizza was huge, which is what I like. The sauce was amazing. The cheese, oh my lord. That was some good cheese. Thepepperoni was awesome too! Crazy how something as simple as a pepperoni pizza can be so delicious when made correctly. This willnow be my go-to pizza joint! Read more

Perfect New York style pizza! Awesome atmosphere and they have draft beer. Local bread for the sandwiches. The bathrooms are... single use so be sure to go before you get here. Read more

This is the best mom and pop Italian restaurant in town. People lining out the door to get in. Everything went surprisingly... quick for pickup. The prices are very reasonable. Ordered Italian sausage sub with peppers and onions, garlic knots that tastelike escargot (we ate a few before the picture). Also an Italian sub not in pic. Everything was perfect. Read more