Reviews for Athens Pizza & Family Restaurant in Keene, NH
So sad the new owners changed all the ingredients and quality. Athens was such a tradition. We gave them multiple chances. The... new owners have totally opted for cheaper ingredients and quality. Oh well. Guess I didn't need that much pizza and chickenparms. So sad Read more
We have had many excellent experiences here over the years, but our past four or five visits have been quite disappointing. It... all culminated with a Friday night delivery order placed at 8:30pm that never showed up. We reached out the following day toinquire about a refund and were given lots of push back. When getting a refund for a failure by the business becomes a tug ofwar, why bother supporting that business? Read more
I absolutely love this pizza. If I travel to Keene, I try to make it a point to come here for some. It's never changed, it... tastes the same every time I've come here over the last 20 years. The place is clean, the staff is super friendly. It's busy, soif you eat in, there will be a wait. But it's worth it. Read more
After an hour wait, Hair in the food and no sauce with my wings. Ordered from here over 10 years. Plenty of complaints but took... it anyway and when I called to talk about the hair in my food asking nothing in return, was put on with the owner and I wastold, ?everyone?s hair is tied back, I?m looking around now and it?s all good.? Sorry but I have kids and a schedule and can?tafford the time to reorder and wait to inspect food and to get it redelivered. No real response to either of my concerns exceptthat I should make sure I get sauce and that the pizza is good; inspect and replace. Why am I ordering from you then? That?syour responsibility and would hope that would be your priority. Definitely going somewhere else next time. Read more
I try to patronize 3 pizza places in Keene. I won?t name the others out if respect for Athens. Athens has always been reliable... in quality and service. Their staff is always busy, so if the service is quick and to the point, that?s ok with me. The pizzasauce is a little on the sweet side (which isn?t my preference but I still good). The crust is very good and the toppings aregenerous. Oh, and their cheese sticks are always a must when ordering. Read more
This place was super busy, but there was a reason why it's so busy. The food was great. We really enjoyed the grinders that we... ordered and the salads are huge all of the portions are really big. We will definitely come back. But you might want to orderahead by phone. The weight can be a little bit longer, just because of the number of people that eat there. But it'sunderstandable after you eat the food. Read more
Pizza is probably my favorite food. I've been all over the country and tried pizza everywhere I've been. New York and Chicago,... sorry Athens is better. This is by far the best pizza I've ever had. This is not my first time at Athens, and won't be my last.I've made several trips to NH from my home in PA and some trips have been centered around getting Athens Pizza. My go to pie isthe family size pepperoni and mushroom with a side of honey mustard for dipping. The honey mustard was suggested by a local,which sounded weird and kinda gross to me, but it's delicious IMO. I've tried this combo with pizza from other places across thecountry. It just doesn't taste right. Athens is the real deal. Best pizza in the country! Read more
Ordered a family size pizza from them, they said it was going to be there between 30-45 mins, didn?t come for over and hour.... When I received the pizza it was so squished the toppings were stuck to the top of the box. I proceeded to cal the store andask for a refund on the pizza, they then said they would send a driver to get the squished pizza and bring it back to the storeand remake it. I then told them I have already waited over and hour and didn?t want to make my 5 year old wait any longer that Iwould eat said pizza I just wanted money back for it. They then told me they would refund me but they would need to come get thepizza. I asked them what I was suppose to feed my child and they replied with you can take 2 pieces out for her and we will bethere to come get the pizza. Needless to say how they deal with situations like this is ridiculous. I will NEVER order from thisplace again. Not to mention my French fries and pizza were both cold. Read more