Reviews for Sticky Fingers Ice Creams and Delectables in Kauneonga Lake, NY

What can I say? This is such a beautiful and fun ice cream parlor to visit and get ice cream. All the ice cream here is so... fresh, creamy and delicious. Service is so friendly and helpful. If you visit this neighborhood you have to stop at StickyFingers and treat the whole family. Super child friendly. Highly recommended! Read more

This is probably one of the best ice cream shops we have ever visited. Small in size but plenty of seating outside or you can... enjoy your treat in your car. The owner is delightful and organized in taking orders (we were a party of 7). Also and this isHUGE for my son and I?. the vegan options are delicious!!We both tried two flavors and forgot we were having dairy free icecream. We went there a total of 3 times while staying nearby. We tried another ice cream spot but there was no comparison inflavor, freshness and quality! Read more

The staff was so friendly. My only complaint would the length of wait time. It was a summer Saturday and they should definitely... have at least three people working. However I would like to add being the ice cream was excellent it was worth the wait. Read more

The perfect pit stop after a long day at the beach. The ice cream is locally made and it?s always fresh! The owner is very sweet... and a great conversationalist. Plenty of seating available but parking can be limited, depending on when you arrive. Overall, Ihighly recommend this place. 10/10. Read more

The best ice cream I've ever had hands down! The killer chocolate was out of this world and the lavender was to die for! A must... stop Read more

Just visit at Sticky Fingers last weekend. The Best Ice Cream I have enjoyed in a long time. So creamy and the flavor is... delicious. Next trip I will try that wonderful smelling homemade soup. You must stop in the hidden treasure. Enjoy and relaxat one of the outside tables. Thanks James for a great experience and say hello to Tara. CU soon Laura and Frank Read more

Omg this place is a hidden little gem in Kauneonga Lake!! The owner/proprietor is James he?s such an amazing, kind, genuine... person who truly loves making people happy with his soups (which are homemade by him and are so delicious! You don?t need to adda thing to them!) ice cream, sandwiches and warm atmosphere. Even tho you are at a restaurant (rated the best restaurant inKauneonga lake!) you feel like you?re a guest in a close friends home. His food is comforting, literally exquisite and they evenhave a little play area for kids! Love this place and as long as I?m here I will be a regular ?????? Read more

Pure, delicious Ice Cream, no artificial colors or preservatives. I ordered the pistachio, my wife ordered the almond joy, my... daughter ordered the killer chocolate, and my son ordered the lavender. All of them were super delicious and easily digestible.We cant wait to go back ???? Read more