Reviews for Erbelli's Gourmet Pizzeria, Italian Bistro & Pub in Kalamazoo, MI

Just went out for pizza at Erbellis and really was hoping to have a great night with some friends. I ordered a split pizza one... side with no meat and the other with meat. However our pizza was covered in pepperoni all the way around the pizza. I thoughtmaybe one slice I?d get a few mistake slices here and there but no. I told the waitress about what happened and she said thatthe staff could make us another small pizza. I was okay with that but it took roughly 40 minutes to have my remade pizza comeout. We get the bill and we were charged for the remade pizza and the pizza that was messed up?!? We waited for 2 and half hourstotal including sitting and waiting for a table beforehand. The waitress also messed up the margarita special and charged usfull price? The pricing for the margaritas were fixed shortly after we told her, but she simply had no idea what the specialswere when we asked. Really frustrating and disappointing in the overall experience. Not worth the money or the time! Do better! Read more

Erbelli's is a fantastic place to eat! Their pizza and bread sticks truly are the best! We arrived at 8 pm which is the time for... last seating, we were fortunate enough, through their kindness let us come in and sit down to eat. Very much thanks to them! Read more

Due to the lack of room in the restaraunt there was a small wait time. Although the table we were seated at I saw empty the... moment we were standing around waiting. After about 15 minutes we were taken to that table to be seated. I enjoyed the food,but my wife found hers quite salty. There seemed to be an issue with not enough waitresses. Our waitress did a fantastic job. Read more

Nice bar! Appears to be a clean place, plenty of tv?s if you?re into that.

I just paid $75 for two medium pizzas and a chef's salad. It was absolutely horrible. The pizza was a wet, mushy mess. SIMPLY... AWFUL. INEDIBLE. Update: The contact provided by owner isn't an actual email address. All I find is a generic form on the website; I prefer a direct contact, but I guess I'll try that. Update: the owner contacted me and made this right with a refund anda gift card. I appreciate it. Read more

Heading home with my loot! This was hands down the best food ive ever eaten. I can die now knowing Ive lived life to the... fullest. We got the applewood candied bacon alfredo pizza, the shishkbob and the protien pizza. The staff was super attentiveand friendly too. Read more

Oh yeah I like a little salad to go with my croutons. Nice little salad and pizza combo for lunch today at @erbellis in... Kalamazoo. The thick sliced pepperoni was an epiphany. Cool little local place. Nice portions and great service. Read more

Ordered carry out tonight and everything was delicious. We tried the prosciutto bites, chicken wings, portobello pizza,... portobello ravioli and another pasta dish with mushrooms, sun dried tomatoes and pesto sauce. Thanks for the great dinner. Read more