Reviews for Goodfella's Pizza in Port St. Lucie, FL
Terrible Food. Right before Hurricane Nicole hit yesterday 11/09/2022. afterwork went there and ordered 2 calzones.... Obviously... they cant make a decent calzone... it was so overcooked my wife and i could barely eat it. I mean it was liteally hard as arock..They do not know how to cook here. Not friendly either. Needless to say ,was overpriced,nearly 50.00 usd. size was greathowever just barely edible. Won't ever eat Goodfella's Pizza again.Avoid like the plague. Read more
2nd delivery order from this place. I ordered 12 regular wings, they brought boneless wings. I called and they immediately... replaced them. I don't eat breading or boneless wings but they seem heavily breaded. The regular wings are Smashing!!! They tellyou 45mins to 1hr for delivery no matter time of day or busyness and both deliveries were about an hour. The replacement foodwas about 15mins which is super fast for delivery. I'm satisfied for sure and I'll continue to order delivery. Also the deliveryis free! Tip your driver a decent tip! Read more
We love this place, ordered here a bunch of times and never had any issues. The food is always ready quick. The pizzas are... always consistent quality and the calzones are BY FAR the best in the area, believe me we've tried them all around here. Theyare a bit pricier than other places but its definitely worth it. Super satisfied, we will be back Read more
Man, I love Goodfellas; first and foremost. I?ve been going here since I was a baby, I grew up in Fort Pierce. The ladies on the... phone are super awesome, and they have the best pie and subs around. Or at least up until a month or two ago. Our pizzas havebeen floppy and undercooked, unless we order it ?well-done? then it is cooked how it was the wayi I remember. I ordered mymother her Italian sub, and when we received it, it was cold, had no cheese, and didn?t have any dressing on it. This was oncea 5-star review I had to edit, and I refuse to give this place any lower than 3 stars because I know the immensely deliciouspotential this place has. Goodfellas is a staple in our community, and I will return; I just hope the quality of the foodreturns to what it was once upon a time. EDIT: okay brought this down to a one star because dude what the F is this??(pictures) Read more
This place is my go to for pizza. It's the best I've found in Florida since moving down here from New England a few years back.... The only other food I've ordered from them was a meatball sub, which I wasn't crazy about, so I can't comment on the other itemson their menu yet, but I really, really like their pizza! Read more
I order pasta and sandwiches from this location all the time, and I love the food... Usually. Last night we decided to order... pizzas and wings. The wings were good, but someone didn't put the lid on the hot sauce correctly so it was spilled all over thebag with the other sauces and fried mushrooms, which were cooked in 2 batches, as some were burnt and some were light colored.The pizzas were not good. They barely had toppings (I actually thought I didn't get the bacon on one until I found a few tinypieces) and on top of that they were cold and slightly doughy. At just over $17 a piece, we were all really disappointed. Idon't know if it was an off night or what, but from now on, I will stick to only pasta or sandwiches from this location. Read more
I just ordered takeout for at the last minute and all this was ready in 20 minutes! I regularly order from here and it is always... very consistent. It was thoroughly enjoyed by all. I had to write a review. Great friendly staff too. Thank you! Read more
I order from here every now and then and lately they have been god awful. Last time they charged me for meat lovers and only... gave me pepperoni, they said they would refund me the extra money and they never did. Today I ordered a pizza with ONLY steakand I got onions, steak, peppers and mushrooms. One of my family members is very allergic to mushrooms so this could have endedbadly. Once we called the ?manager? said she can?t do anything and hung up on us. Great customer service. Read more