Reviews for Casey's in Jefferson, WI
Went for gas at NOON on Sunday 10/2/2022. Gave the cashier $100 bill and he goes "I can't take that I don't have change." I said... it is noon ask your manager/supervisor he said no one is here. Casey's lost our business and we went to another gas stationdown the road told them what happened pyramid started. Read more
My kids love the pizza. We have done several orders so far and there have been zero issues. I have ordered via the app and... each time, it's made and ready at the time I selected. The coupon deals have been great. The employees inside have been niceand friendly. The store and bathrooms have been clean the few times we have gone inside. Lots of products to pick from. Ofcourse prices are a tad higher, but this is not a grocery store ;) Pricing is comparable to KT and other gas stations in thearea. The app is a great way to save $$ and also can use your rewards and back to my kids schools. They have been a goodsupporter of our public schools in the area, we appreciate it. Thank you! Read more
Close to home, but come on, $36 for a 12 pack of Mikes and a medium 1 topping pizza? You've got to be out of your mind to pay... that much! Pizza was narsty, I'll grab a Jacks for $2.63 at Walmart and a 12 pack of Mikes at Kwik Trip for $10 next time. Read more
Kitchen staff not overly friendly. Felt more inconvenient for the kitchen person to have to stop and make a pizza for customer... who waited for one then didnt even thank or smile to customer when it was handed to her. Read more
I love the new look! I stopped in for a cappuccino and donuts. I like the people who work there and the food/drinks. My... favorite gas station, hands down! Read more
People working at the Jefferson Casey's have always been friendly and helpful. It feels like a small neighborhood store but now... with delicious Casey's pizza! Read more
I ordered a taco pizza and even though they don't have the circular crust yet it was still a delicious pizza and Nick did an... amazing job of making it,I will DEFINITELY be going back and ordering more!!! Read more
Incredibly helpful with me ordering a beer cheese pizza even tho their ingredients were frozen. Pizza was amazing. Super... friendly staff always. Love this store Read more