Reviews for Brooklyn's Lobster Shack in Jeannette, PA
Delicious extremely large portions so bring an appetite or take a box home for another 2 meals in my case ????. Overall a great... seafood place or if not in the mood you can order from their pizza place next door plenty to chose from with hoagies & otheritems. Will be back! Read more
I?m giving this place four stars, because overall the place was VERY CUTE, clean, the waitress was nice, and we had great... service. They had complementary beers, which was cool. The food was everything I was hoping for. It was absolutely delicious.The price is high,sure, but I took MORE than half my pasta home. I didn?t even make a dent in it at dinner. They don?t cheapyou out on the amount of seafood served on their platters as well. YOU PAY FOR WHAT YOU GET, and overall I think, the pricesweren?t outrageous for the amount of meat I had on both my dishes. Plus the salad and garlic toast. There was sooo many friesleft over with humps of meat still left on them. (we got to share between three of us) I came home and re heated them in the airfryer a day later and they tasted just as good. The only thing I wasn?t pleased about was the bottles of water. I?m a bigdrinker, especially when eating and I ended up paying $8 in bottled water. At that point I may as well of gotten a pop or a tea.Now this is where my, almost five star rating is getting lost. I wanted another water to go, but by that time, the waitress hadalready brought our check by. Which she didn?t ask how we wanted to pay. Which isn?t a huge deal, but there was three of us, twotogether and one separate, when we realized she put us all on one check, we asked her if we could have separate checks. She toldus there was no possible way she could do that now, since she already entered it into the system?.. our only option was to payin full or split fire tilt in half. Oh well, all and all I had a pleasant experience and I will be coming back and bringingalong others who?ve also wanted to give this place a try. Read more
The waitress was on the ball , But with the free draft beers they would fill a pitcher up and it would sit over there which in... return made the beer very warm not sure about anyone else but I like my beer ice cold not warm. The Mac and cheese was mushy asin the noodles were over cooked and was one big clunck and very, very dry. The baked potatoes were good. We got the big platterwhich included legs, shrimp and lobster tail it was brought out to us cold, we were on a time frame so wife ate some of it. Itook one bite of the Mac and cheese and put the lid back on the container and pushed it to the side. Everything is veryexpensive at this place I spent close to $100 and we pretty much didn't eat any of it . I think wife ate the lobster tail eventhough it was cold and she ate about 4 shrimp the rest went to waste. I did leave the waitress a good tip only because she wason the ball and its not her fault the food was not good and cold. So I would say that this place might be good for some peoplebut not for us. Read more
Loved the food! Any Sunday Im in town I will make my way to this wonderful delicious establishment!
Conneticut lobster roll was outstanding. Also had the surf and turf fries which were good. The filet mignon on the fries was... overcooked and would have liked the temperature to be on the medium to medium well side so that was the only negative. Nice thatfree beer is offered as well. Read more
The food was delicious and the service was amazing! It's a little far from where my friends and I live so we ordered almost... everything. LOL Everything was so good. If you get a salad be sure to taste the homemade Italian dressing!!! Read more
The Lobster was plentiful. Best dish is the lobster, shrimp, and filet fries by far. The lobster could use some more butter... and lemon. My least favorite part was the roll for the lobster rolls, it seemed like a hot dog bun. We drove an hour to eatthere, and it was worth it. Just come with a lot of cash. Oh and they gave us free Blue Moon beer also. Read more
Lobster Fries were fresh cut and delicious! Perfect for sharing. The place feels quaint and cozy and was worth the drive.... Excellent service, quality and ambiance. Read more