Reviews for I Love NY Pizza & Bar Jasper in Jasper, GA
Man, what a bummer this place was tonight. We?ve been numerous times before and the service was excellent and the food equally... so. Today, not even close. Fries pickles were waaaay overcooked. The pickle should be soft NOT crunchy. My calzone wasundercooked, the Ricotta cheese was still cool. WTH! We had finished almost our entire meal before my daughter got hers. Sheordered a pizza, come on man. Best part was how our leftovers were cleared before we could box them up. I told the waitress thatwe were going to take them home and took them anyway. Like, seriously! I think we?re done with this place. Time to try someplace with better service. Read more
We stopped here on our way back from Lake Winnie on a Thursday night. It was karaoke night and the singers were good, some were... really, really impressive. The food was DELICIOUS, the prices were good and the staff seemed to like their job. We are fromKentucky, but want to go back again in the near future. Loved this place. Read more
This is a great place!!! If you want a great Long Island Ice Tea, then definitely this is the place!!! I have had a lot of... different food here, zucchini sticks are the favorite, but everything is good. Try it, you won?t be disappointed. Read more
So I read all the reviews before going and was a little unsure based on some of the negative comments... but we went and I'm... glad we did. First of all, the comments about this isn't a NY style pizza place must have eaten somewhere else. My wife and Iare from NY and have had pizza all over the world (literally), we know NY style, and this is authentic to the small town we arefrom in NY. In fact, it was almost identical which made us very happy! See picture of the NY Sausage Stromboli attached. This isexactly what it should look like and how it should be served. The pies are thin crust and greasy and that's exactly how they aresupposed to be. Word of caution to those who may come here and want food on the table in minutes... good NY style places cook toorder and they are doing as many or more to go orders as they are in house, so pack your patience or maybe this isn't the rightplace for you. If you are patient, it's well worth the wait and you won't be disappointed. Read more
I have food allergies and they were awesome. They double checked my severity since my food would use the same oven and they... couldn't absolutely guarantee it wouldn't come into contact with an allergen in the kitchen. Thank you for being thorough andknowing to ask about that! The pizza was good, too! Read more
I absolutely LOVE this spot!!! So far, I have not ordered a single thing that wasn?t delicious. My usual ?go-to? order is a... pepperoni calzone, with tomato, spinach and garlic, as well as the lemon pepper wings. I?ve also had some of their pasta, theirhot subs (CHICKEN PARMIGIANA ????) and their cannolis!!! This isn?t the type of restaurant I would normally seek-out but BOY amI glad I did!!! Everything is fantastic! Read more
Large and comfy outside seating and we love the pizza! Dinner was so good tonight! Feels like family every time we visit them!... Melissa always makes sure we are happy with our experience! Read more
The atmosphere here is beautiful. Dim lighting when eating inside. Our server Bretton was awesome. Our food was so hot & fresh.... They had some singing going on outside. Will definitely go back & try something else. Read more