Reviews for TonyD's New York Pizza & Restaurant in Jacksonville, FL

November 2022 excellent across the board. September 2022 busy but great service and food. Camron does a great job. July 2022... and with the exception of the dining room expanding which makes the dining are bigger all remains the same...outstanding!!! Think Fantastic and you still need another adjective. Everything was super pizza, pasta and salad enough for all6 of ua 6 years old to 75. This is not chain or franchise Italian this was old fashion great food. If you're not eating here youare missing something wonderful. Read more

Food is good, server was great. service at the front entrance good not be bothered. The lady behind the counter told me someone... would help me shortly. Waited 10min to be told hello and added to wait list. No big deal. Shortly after that, a couple came inowner sat them after we had been waiting 20min. I was in with my hungry 5 year old. This place was recommended unfortunately not the best first impression. Read more

LITERALLY THE BEST PIZZA SPOT and the most authentic NEW YORK STYLE RESTAURANT I've ever had!! This is now my go to spot! MAN... THEY KILL IT EVERYTIME!!! Read more

Being from NY, I am very picky about pizza and Italian food and I must say both are GREAT here! I also thought it was so nice to... see the owner in the restaurant on a busy night helping the servers bring drinks to tables, clean up, and just overall careabout the place. It really shows through the food and service! Highly recommend. :) Read more

The Pizza was amazing! Best NY pizza we've had since moving 30+ years ago. I'm all about the crust and sauce. We had the... Grandma's pizza. Definitely going back and taking friends! Read more

Amazing!!! Real New York pizza, and they have Sicilian. I haven't seen that outside of NY. We've been back several times since... discovering this gem. Great menu. Everything that we've tried has been delicious. If you love NY pizza, give it a try. You won'tregret it. Read more

This place was PACKED when I arrived with my family, no where to even stand. That is all I needed to know to stick around, we... waited 45 minutes to dine in and the wait was worth it. The food was delicious and the staff was so friendly. Although they weresuper busy, all staff was very polite and mannered. Best Margherita pizza in Jacksonville, and the wings were amazing! Read more

First time going and recommend by a friend. I have to say that was the best pizza me and my wife had in a very long time. We... got the large NY special pizza and I got it to take home. The pizza was still hot and fresh. This will be the go to place forpizza and I'm sure for other food options. Look how delicious this pizza looks. Read more