Reviews for New Berlin Fish House & Oyster Bar in Jacksonville, FL

Very nice dinner and we loved the decor!! We had the stuffed group and the captains platter. We loved all of the seafood, we... both got corn and mashed potatoes as our sides, we are not fans of the mashed potatoes. The meals were good sized and thecondiments were very good. Next time we will share the captains platter and not leave so stuffed????. Abby was a good serverand she had a big group right next to us. Read more

We should have left when we first day down and they said they couldn't serve any drinks with liquor, which is a huge part of... their menu. Oysters had shells/sand in them which made them inedible, but the manager was great and took them off. Pimentocheese was great. The steak and the Calamari was way over salted. Shrimp and grits was the star of the show. Crab legs were alittle over cooked but still delicious. It was a Friday night so it took about an hour for our food to come out, but we reserveda seat through Google Assistant and were able to be seated right away. I would come back, but I would only order pimento cheeseand shrimp and grits. Read more

Great food. A seafood lover's dream! Great prices for the quality of food served! The shrimp and grits is fantastic and the... stuffed grouper made my wife very happy! Definitely worth trying out! I have a feeling you'll be back! Read more

New Berlin Fish House and Oyster Bar was really good but it was a Friday night and they were short staffed so it took a long... time to get our food. The grouper with pimento cheese grits was delicious, the oysters were fresh and tasty. Everyone enjoyedtheir food. They don?t have any liquor at this location but have beer and wine. Nice place with good food and the servers werefriendly but like I said very slow to come out of the kitchen. Read more

The decor and atmosphere definitely give you the feeling of being at a dock side seafood place. The calamari was decent as were... the crab legs. They should probably pull the liquor drinks from the menu since they do not have a liquor license and thus I wasa bit disappointed to find that out when I tried to order one. Aside from that it's an alright restaurant. The wait staff isyoung so give them some leeway as small things that might be missed aren't done intentionally. Read more

This place is incredible and I would recommend it to anyone! Our waitress Hannah provided the best service we've had in months... and asked if there was anything we wanted frequently. The food was also above and beyond what we expected and the quantity wasworth the money. The fried green tomatoes and stuffed grouper were very good and definitely worth a shot. Read more

New Berlin Fish House was awesome! Everything was fresh (even the tea) and my family and I had a great time. We had a little bit... of everything. I had the gator tail and the stuffed grouper....The gator tail was delicious! Not too heavily breaded and thepetal sauce that came with was great too...The best part was that grouper though...The crabmeat was so sweet and the cheese wasa nice touch... It's so great to see such a good restaurant with fresh locally caught fish has popped up in my old neighborhood!We didn't have anything like that when I was little ???? Oh and our server, Carmen was top-notch...She was really busy and wehad a party of 7 and we never once wanted for a thing! Read more

Great dinner and great service! We had the Captains platter and the crab cakes. Both were very good. The coleslaw side is the... great creamy type. Both the fries and sweet potato fries were okay. The cocktail sauce and tarter sauce both seemed to behomemade, and were really good. We got the Key Lime Pie and chocolate cake we?re both very good. The key lime pie was creamyand very flavorful. Probably in the top 10 key lime pies I?ve had. Read more