Reviews for Five Star Pizza in Jacksonville, FL
I really liked the pizza, just wouldn't recommend getting mushrooms on it because they didn't look the best. Garlic biscuits... were good, bready, but good. Overall a good experience. Read more
2 and a half hours to get food. First time they went to the wrong house. Manager said he'd remake it & bring it himself inside... of 30 minutes. An hour later, they had no idea when it was coming. At the 2 &1 hour mark, somebody pulled in the drive, didn'tget out, didn't knock & threw her car in reverse before I opened the screen door & walked outside. Front door open, all thelights on .. she was just going to leave. So cold pizza, wings & bread later... Won't do that again. Read more
I was nervous to try a new pizza place. I just moved to town and used a chain pizza place once and the pizza was the worst I had... ever tasted. So I tried Five Star and was pleasantly surprised. The delivery was super fast - even on a holiday! The pizza waswell made and just as advertised. The prices are also reasonable. Overall, a great experience. I highly recommend this pizzajoint! Read more
Always amazing. Always on time. If you ever are in the mood for great pizza here in Murray Hill, Jax - FIVE STAR PIZZA is the... spot. DO not think of this place like your average pizza parlor. Nope. Real CHEESE. Real sauce. Not to fail to mention the staffis great. Folks they send me a holiday card every year - with a coupon. You can not go wrong here. Order up and find out. Read more
They use to make really good buffalo chicken pizza. I dont know if this location got a new cook or they changed the way they... make it but this is like the 3rd time ive ordered a buffalo chicken pizza and its super soggy as if the buffalo sauce and ranchwas put on after the pizza baked. Pools of ranch and buffalo sauce sitting on the pizza. It soaked throught the pizza making itappear and feel like some slop and the sauces were running everywhere making a mess smh so soggy that when we picked up a slicehalf the slice stayed in the box. Read more
Everything tasted absolutely amazing! Mild wings and and everything pizza! Service was awesome given I ordered about 20 minutes... before midnight. It didn't take long at all. And everything was made to perfection. I asked for the wings well done and theywere exactly that, not too burnt, but not too undercooked either. And the pizza was great, just missing the garlic butter crustI ordered, which is an honest mistake and I still give 5 stars in hope next time they don't forget it. Definitely my new go tospot for pizza! Read more
I definitely cannot complain. Ordered online and had a gift card they placed on my door around Christmas time that didn't have a... code, so I informed them in the special comments/delivery instructions. When they got to my house they honored it with noproblem. Pizza was fresh and hot when it arrived and very cheesy, which is obviously great! The garlic butter knots were good aswell. Will definitely order here again. Delivery was also fast as well and the driver was very polite. Read more
Beware of the disingenuous, dishonest marketing and bad customer service from 5 Star Pizza. I was mailed a $10 "no strings... attached" coupon in the mail and called to redeem it on a large pepperoni pizza carry out special, which I think is about $12.The guy on the phone says no, we can't do that because then the pizza would be free for you. Are you serious? Then don't send mea no strings attached gift card! I attached a picture so you can see that there is no language on here that disqualifies usingin on top of other specials, or anything. That is literally what no strings attached means. The call made me feel like I'm justsome freeloader trying to take advantage of them... not someone who has ordered hundreds of pizzas from them in the past. Idon't understand the strategy of mailing your customers a Holliday gift card only to ruin the goodwill by being a cheapskate andmaking up restrictions because you dont feel like redeeming it. Read more