Reviews for Sicilian Delight in Ithaca, NY
They have HALAL pizza! FANTASTIC staff! If you ask them, they can use halal pepperoni and use clean cutter that have not touched... pork. And pizza tastes amazing. Best pizza I have eaten in Ithaca so far! We are eating there every week Read more
I haven't found a pizza place that beats Sicilian Delight here in the mall at Ithaca. Its cooked perfectly every time I come... here. Its real thin crust usually and comes out perfect. The crust is NEVER over-cooked (burnt). This includes theirStromboli's, pizza rolls, and I am sure everything else they make. This is my favorite place to eat when I come to Ithaca. Inaddition to the already delicious food the staff is super friendly and grateful for your business. This business is doingthings right. Keep up the good work guys! Read more
Quite possibly the best reason to go to Shops at Ithaca Mall. Sicilian Delight was everything its name suggests. Authentic,... quality food with fast and incredible service. I went there just looking for a cheese pizza for the wife and kids. I wound upadding a meat lovers? stromboli and some garlic knots because they looked and smelled incredible. The staff was so friendly andaccommodating. I don?t want to forget the best part! The specials! Their daily specials are so reasonable. Each day hadsomething new to try at great prices. As a family of 4 that means a lot to me. I see myself calling ahead for take-out andbringing home this new family favorite for dinner often. Do yourself a favor and visit this Central New York restaurant thattastes like New York City Pizza. Read more
I would take a picture of the rest of the food I got but it was so good I couldn't hold off! Meatballs are amazing and made... fresh as well as my slice of chicken bacon ranch pizza. The NY cheesecake is so good too!!! Super friendly and and awesomeexperience. Best place to eat in the mall for sure. Read more
The pizza, rolls, and calzones were amazing. The crust is perfect - crispy on the outside, soft inside. Delicious variety of... flavors, and to top it off a very reasonable price. It's a shame the mall isn't busier, because this place deserves a biggercrowd. Read more
Amazing new owners very kind ! I haven?t been to the mall in a long time. Decided to stop. i purchased a variety of their... slices they all tasted amazing my kids and family loved it all. We will be back for the jumbo hot wings amd more pizza Crust is crispy flavors are robust. Highly recommend for everyone Prices are great too Read more
Sicilian Delight has the loveliest and nicest staff/cook in the town! I was actually here yesterday as a door dash driver. When... I arrived there, they told me that the pizza would take few minutes and suddenly asked me if I want any drink! At first, Ithought I heard wrong and actually told them I was just a delivery man. But with the biggest smile, they once again offered me acup for fountain drink and said it?s their offering for having to wait! :) Really hard to find restaurants like this these dayswith such a friendly staffs and positive energy. Definitely going back with my family for pizzas! The pizzas that I saw whilewaiting looked so great as well! Read more
If I can give 6 stars I would. They are so friendly. The people that own it treat you like family. They are not picky about... every single thing and often give you free things. They treat you like you are a king. They remember number of kids and nameseven when we haven't been there much. It's amazing the quality of service. I have never seen anything like it. The pizza isamazing. The Stromboli is amazing. It is not greasy. It is 100% New York City authentic. And it is always consistentlygood. This is my new goto location for pizza when I am in ithaca. I only wish they had one closer to us in Elmira. I oftendrive an hour just to come here for lunch. Don't let it fool you that they are in a mall. I told my brother about it and thefirst thought he had was "mall pizza" is gross. But after he tried it he was amazed. Read more